Evaluation of MTT reducers and strongly colored substances in the Short Time Exposure test method for assessing eye irritation potential.

Abstract

The Short Time Exposure (STE) test evaluates eye irritation potential using a 3-(4,5-di-methylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide (MTT) assay. MTT assays may underpredict results for some substances that directly reduce MTT (i.e., MTT reducers) or interfere with absorbance because of their strong color (i.e., strongly colored substances). Based on previous research, we selected 25 substances as MTT reducers. Of these, 13 were expected to be MTT reducers at 5% dilution (5% MTT reducers) of the STE test condition. These 13 substances were then tested to determine whether the results were interfered from direct MTT reduction. Those 5% MTT reducers that were classified as irritants based on in vivo data were identified as irritants by the STE test. In addition, the low cell viability results at 5% dilution suggested that direct MTT reduction had not occurred. Next, the remaining 5% MTT reducers that were classified as non-irritants based on in vivo data were identified as non-irritants by the STE test. We then examined two strongly colored substances. One was classified as an irritant based on in vivo data and was confirmed as an irritant by the STE test. The other was classified as a non-irritant by the STE test. This was further evaluated using a medium that did not contain MTT; the result indicated that it was a non-irritant correctly. In conclusion, the STE test is useful for evaluating eye irritation potential without the drawback of underprediction for MTT reducers and strongly colored substances.