Gusti Bagus Yudhi Jaya Putra Atmaja, G. M. Wibowo, Bagus Abimanyu
{"title":"mri机器在巴厘岛的性能测试","authors":"Gusti Bagus Yudhi Jaya Putra Atmaja, G. M. Wibowo, Bagus Abimanyu","doi":"10.31983/JIMED.V4I2.4000","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Backgroud: The research of performance test of MRI machines were done by doing performance test of nine different parameters in three hospitals in the province of Bali, where in two of these three hospitals are having troubled MRI machines which directly affected the image quality and therefore this research is also aimed to find out the performance of MRI machines in some hospitals in the province of Bali and intended as a baseline data if there will another test. Methods: This research is a quantitative study with survey approach. The tools and materials for this research were three MRI machines, which was consisted of two 1,5 Tesla machines and a 0,3 Tesla machine, phantom ACR, and MRI head coil. The data were collected by doing nine MRI performance testing procedures with ACR (2015) as a guideline and then the data were analyzed using international standards issued by ACR (2015). Results: Visual checklist test result of all the hospitals get 12 pass every day from the first day to the twentieth day. SNR test in Badung Regional General Hospital obtain measurement results of 268.17 and in The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital at 15.78 and at Sanglah Central General Hospital of 2.4. To test the artifact analysis only in The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital only found one type of artifact is the artifact geometric distortion. In testing the high contrast resolution in Sanglah Central General Hospital and Badung Regional General Hospital get the same result, namely insert a separate resolution of up to a third group, and the The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital insert a separate resolution to the second group. The test results in low contrast resolution Sanglah Central General Hospital and Badung Regional General Hospital get the same result, namely that there are 10 spokes are visible, then the The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital number of spokes that appear are 9 spokes. In testing the slice thickness accuracy in Sanglah Central General Hospital get the standard deviation of measurement of 5.12mm and in Badung Regional General Hospital get the standard deviation and the measurement of 0.64mm in The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital get the standard deviation of measurement of 0.48mm. Results of the geometric accuracy test in The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital has a difference measurement of 4.2mm X axis, Y-axis of 1.3mm, and has no difference in the Z-axis, in Badung Regional General Hospital has a difference of X-axis measurement of -3.1mm, have no difference in the Y axis the Z axis of 2mm, in Sanglah Central General Hospital has a difference measurement of 1.36mm X axis, Y-axis and Z-axis of 0.39mm for -3.53mm. The test results slice position accuracy in Sanglah Central General Hospital get the standard deviation measurements for -1.33mm, in The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital of 0.85mm, and in Badung Regional General Hospital of -0.3mm. For the test setup and table position accuracy throughout the hospital to get the same measurement is 5mm. Conclusion: Out of nine parameters in the test : only four parameters, which were high contrast resolution test, low contrast resolution test, slice position accuracy test, and setup and table position accuracy test, that met the international standards in all hospitals, whereas all the hospital didn’t meet the international standards in geometric accuracy test. There were two hospitals that didn’t meet the international standards in signal to noise ratio test, while one hospital didn’t meet the standards in artifact analysis test and slice thickness accuracy test.","PeriodicalId":205622,"journal":{"name":"Jurnal Imejing Diagnostik (JImeD)","volume":"18 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2018-07-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"PERFOMANCE TEST OF MRI MACHINES IN THE PROVINCE OF BALI\",\"authors\":\"Gusti Bagus Yudhi Jaya Putra Atmaja, G. M. Wibowo, Bagus Abimanyu\",\"doi\":\"10.31983/JIMED.V4I2.4000\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"Backgroud: The research of performance test of MRI machines were done by doing performance test of nine different parameters in three hospitals in the province of Bali, where in two of these three hospitals are having troubled MRI machines which directly affected the image quality and therefore this research is also aimed to find out the performance of MRI machines in some hospitals in the province of Bali and intended as a baseline data if there will another test. Methods: This research is a quantitative study with survey approach. The tools and materials for this research were three MRI machines, which was consisted of two 1,5 Tesla machines and a 0,3 Tesla machine, phantom ACR, and MRI head coil. The data were collected by doing nine MRI performance testing procedures with ACR (2015) as a guideline and then the data were analyzed using international standards issued by ACR (2015). Results: Visual checklist test result of all the hospitals get 12 pass every day from the first day to the twentieth day. SNR test in Badung Regional General Hospital obtain measurement results of 268.17 and in The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital at 15.78 and at Sanglah Central General Hospital of 2.4. To test the artifact analysis only in The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital only found one type of artifact is the artifact geometric distortion. In testing the high contrast resolution in Sanglah Central General Hospital and Badung Regional General Hospital get the same result, namely insert a separate resolution of up to a third group, and the The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital insert a separate resolution to the second group. The test results in low contrast resolution Sanglah Central General Hospital and Badung Regional General Hospital get the same result, namely that there are 10 spokes are visible, then the The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital number of spokes that appear are 9 spokes. In testing the slice thickness accuracy in Sanglah Central General Hospital get the standard deviation of measurement of 5.12mm and in Badung Regional General Hospital get the standard deviation and the measurement of 0.64mm in The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital get the standard deviation of measurement of 0.48mm. Results of the geometric accuracy test in The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital has a difference measurement of 4.2mm X axis, Y-axis of 1.3mm, and has no difference in the Z-axis, in Badung Regional General Hospital has a difference of X-axis measurement of -3.1mm, have no difference in the Y axis the Z axis of 2mm, in Sanglah Central General Hospital has a difference measurement of 1.36mm X axis, Y-axis and Z-axis of 0.39mm for -3.53mm. The test results slice position accuracy in Sanglah Central General Hospital get the standard deviation measurements for -1.33mm, in The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital of 0.85mm, and in Badung Regional General Hospital of -0.3mm. For the test setup and table position accuracy throughout the hospital to get the same measurement is 5mm. Conclusion: Out of nine parameters in the test : only four parameters, which were high contrast resolution test, low contrast resolution test, slice position accuracy test, and setup and table position accuracy test, that met the international standards in all hospitals, whereas all the hospital didn’t meet the international standards in geometric accuracy test. There were two hospitals that didn’t meet the international standards in signal to noise ratio test, while one hospital didn’t meet the standards in artifact analysis test and slice thickness accuracy test.\",\"PeriodicalId\":205622,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Jurnal Imejing Diagnostik (JImeD)\",\"volume\":\"18 1\",\"pages\":\"0\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"2018-07-01\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Jurnal Imejing Diagnostik (JImeD)\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.31983/JIMED.V4I2.4000\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"\",\"JCRName\":\"\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Jurnal Imejing Diagnostik (JImeD)","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.31983/JIMED.V4I2.4000","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
背景:MRI机器性能测试的研究是通过在巴厘岛省的三家医院进行九种不同参数的性能测试来完成的,这三家医院中的两家都有问题的MRI机器,直接影响了图像质量,因此本研究也旨在找出巴厘岛省一些医院的MRI机器的性能,并打算作为基线数据,如果有另一个测试。方法:采用问卷调查法进行定量研究。本研究使用的工具和材料为3台核磁共振成像仪(两台1,5 Tesla和一台0,3 Tesla)、幻影ACR和MRI头线圈。以ACR(2015)为指导,通过9个MRI性能测试程序收集数据,然后使用ACR(2015)发布的国际标准对数据进行分析。结果:自第1天至第20天,各医院视觉检查表检测结果每天通过12次。巴东地区总医院的信噪比测试的测量结果为268.17,塔巴南总医院董事会的信噪比为15.78,桑格拉中心总医院的信噪比为2.4。仅在塔巴南总医院的板检中发现一种类型的人工制品是几何畸变的人工制品。在桑格拉中央总医院和巴东地区总医院测试高对比度分辨率时,得到了相同的结果,即插入最多第三组的单独分辨率,塔巴南总医院董事会在第二组插入单独分辨率。在低对比度分辨率下Sanglah Central General Hospital和Badung Regional General Hospital的测试结果相同,即有10条辐条可见,那么Tabanan Board General Hospital出现的辐条数是9条。桑拉市中心总医院对切片厚度精度的测量标准差为5.12mm,巴东地区总医院对切片厚度精度的测量标准差为0.64mm,塔巴南市总医院对切片厚度精度的测量标准差为0.48mm。结果塔巴南总医院的几何精度检测结果在X轴差值为4.2mm, Y轴差值为1.3mm, Z轴差值无差异,在巴东地区总医院的X轴差值为-3.1mm, Y轴差值为- Z轴差值为2mm,在桑格拉中心总医院的X轴差值为1.36mm, Y轴差值为-3.53mm, Z轴差值为0.39mm。测试结果:桑格拉中心总医院切片定位精度的标准差测量值为-1.33mm,塔巴南总医院为0.85mm,巴东地区总医院为-0.3mm。对于测试设置和工作台位置的精度在整个医院得到相同的测量是5mm。结论:在测试的9个参数中,所有医院只有高对比度分辨率测试、低对比度分辨率测试、切片位置精度测试、设置和工作台位置精度测试4个参数符合国际标准,而所有医院在几何精度测试中均未达到国际标准。有2家医院的信噪比测试不符合国际标准,1家医院的伪影分析测试和切片厚度精度测试不符合国际标准。
PERFOMANCE TEST OF MRI MACHINES IN THE PROVINCE OF BALI
Backgroud: The research of performance test of MRI machines were done by doing performance test of nine different parameters in three hospitals in the province of Bali, where in two of these three hospitals are having troubled MRI machines which directly affected the image quality and therefore this research is also aimed to find out the performance of MRI machines in some hospitals in the province of Bali and intended as a baseline data if there will another test. Methods: This research is a quantitative study with survey approach. The tools and materials for this research were three MRI machines, which was consisted of two 1,5 Tesla machines and a 0,3 Tesla machine, phantom ACR, and MRI head coil. The data were collected by doing nine MRI performance testing procedures with ACR (2015) as a guideline and then the data were analyzed using international standards issued by ACR (2015). Results: Visual checklist test result of all the hospitals get 12 pass every day from the first day to the twentieth day. SNR test in Badung Regional General Hospital obtain measurement results of 268.17 and in The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital at 15.78 and at Sanglah Central General Hospital of 2.4. To test the artifact analysis only in The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital only found one type of artifact is the artifact geometric distortion. In testing the high contrast resolution in Sanglah Central General Hospital and Badung Regional General Hospital get the same result, namely insert a separate resolution of up to a third group, and the The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital insert a separate resolution to the second group. The test results in low contrast resolution Sanglah Central General Hospital and Badung Regional General Hospital get the same result, namely that there are 10 spokes are visible, then the The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital number of spokes that appear are 9 spokes. In testing the slice thickness accuracy in Sanglah Central General Hospital get the standard deviation of measurement of 5.12mm and in Badung Regional General Hospital get the standard deviation and the measurement of 0.64mm in The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital get the standard deviation of measurement of 0.48mm. Results of the geometric accuracy test in The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital has a difference measurement of 4.2mm X axis, Y-axis of 1.3mm, and has no difference in the Z-axis, in Badung Regional General Hospital has a difference of X-axis measurement of -3.1mm, have no difference in the Y axis the Z axis of 2mm, in Sanglah Central General Hospital has a difference measurement of 1.36mm X axis, Y-axis and Z-axis of 0.39mm for -3.53mm. The test results slice position accuracy in Sanglah Central General Hospital get the standard deviation measurements for -1.33mm, in The Board Of Tabanan General Hospital of 0.85mm, and in Badung Regional General Hospital of -0.3mm. For the test setup and table position accuracy throughout the hospital to get the same measurement is 5mm. Conclusion: Out of nine parameters in the test : only four parameters, which were high contrast resolution test, low contrast resolution test, slice position accuracy test, and setup and table position accuracy test, that met the international standards in all hospitals, whereas all the hospital didn’t meet the international standards in geometric accuracy test. There were two hospitals that didn’t meet the international standards in signal to noise ratio test, while one hospital didn’t meet the standards in artifact analysis test and slice thickness accuracy test.