Building Consistent Transactions with Inconsistent Replication

Application programmers increasingly prefer distributed storage systems with strong consistency and distributed transactions (e.g., Google’s Spanner) for their strong guarantees and ease of use. Unfortunately, existing transactional storage systems are expensive to use—in part, because they require costly replication protocols, like Paxos, for fault tolerance. In this article, we present a new approach that makes transactional storage systems more affordable: We eliminate consistency from the replication protocol, while still providing distributed transactions with strong consistency to applications. We present the Transactional Application Protocol for Inconsistent Replication (TAPIR), the first transaction protocol to use a novel replication protocol, called inconsistent replication, that provides fault tolerance without consistency. By enforcing strong consistency only in the transaction protocol, TAPIR can commit transactions in a single round-trip and order distributed transactions without centralized coordination. We demonstrate the use of TAPIR in a transactional key-value store, TAPIR-KV. Compared to conventional systems, TAPIR-KV provides better latency and better throughput.