{"title":"旧约中神迹故事的研究,以出埃及记第14章的海上事件为中心","authors":"Y. Kim","doi":"10.21731/ctat.2022.86.8","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"This article poses a perennial question of what miracles are and of whether miracles can really happen from the perspectives of the Old Testament and its authors. It aims to clarify the definition of miracles that the books of the Old Testament (to be abbreviated as OT hereafter) describe, to examine its differences from the modern definition of miracles by comparison, and to suggest how to read and understand the miracle stories of the OT. \nOur inquiry about miracles proceeded in three steps. First, I examined the meanings and lexical usages of various terms for miracles in the OT to figure out the definition of miracles that the authors of the OT might have kept in their mind. The terms for miracles are ’ôt, môpët, Gübûrâ, pele, niplä’ôt, Güdôlöt, and the like. Interestingly none of these correspond with the modern terms of miracle. \nSecondly, I analyzed the text of Exodus 14 which narrates the Sea Event, one of the representative miracle stories in the Hebrew Bible. Referring to the achievements of historical critical studies on this text, I distinguished various motives and traditions inherent in the text, and attempted to grasp its core messages, revealed through their polyphonic voices. By and large two themes are found in Exodus 14. One is about God’s sovereignty. God is described as the one who freely exploits either the power of nature or supernatural force and smashes Pharaoh’s chariots and his whole army. The other is about God’s protection for his people and about proper response to it. Since the same God is the one who protects and supports the Israelites, they should fear and trust in him. These themes are repeated in the phrases which recount the Sea Event. By the way, scholars, who tend to acknowledge the historicity of the core substance of the story, accept the naturalistic explanation of the event from the text, while disregarding the supernatural descriptions of it as either a secondary source or a later embellishment. As a result, such attempts lead to neglecting some integral elements in the text. Their efforts to make believe the story, by eliminating supernatural and mythic components of the text, lead to miss the important themes that Exodus 14 conveys. \nThird, it would be necessary to examine the ways in which the ancient Israelites perceived the world, history and nature in order to understand the miracle stories in the OT. They had not questioned the possibility of miracles. Instead, they took it for granted that God can intervene in nature and history at any time he needs since he is the Lord who governs his created world and the world keeps its integrity only with God’s support. \nAncient Israelites’ understanding of miracles is closely connected with their belief that God is always working in the history of salvation. Biblical miracle stories were written down and transmitted for the purpose of strengthening and edifying their faith in God. In this sense, the story of the Sea Event in Exodus 14 had a great influence on the growth of their faith. Therefore, I suggest that a proper way to read the miracle stories in the OT is not to pose a question of whether the miracles that the text presents would be possible or not, but to ask what theological, heuristic, and ethical messages are conveyed through them.","PeriodicalId":370969,"journal":{"name":"The Society of Theology and Thought","volume":"28 ","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2022-06-30","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"A Study of Miracle Stories in the Old Testament, Focused on the Sea Event of Exodus 14\",\"authors\":\"Y. Kim\",\"doi\":\"10.21731/ctat.2022.86.8\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"This article poses a perennial question of what miracles are and of whether miracles can really happen from the perspectives of the Old Testament and its authors. It aims to clarify the definition of miracles that the books of the Old Testament (to be abbreviated as OT hereafter) describe, to examine its differences from the modern definition of miracles by comparison, and to suggest how to read and understand the miracle stories of the OT. \\nOur inquiry about miracles proceeded in three steps. First, I examined the meanings and lexical usages of various terms for miracles in the OT to figure out the definition of miracles that the authors of the OT might have kept in their mind. The terms for miracles are ’ôt, môpët, Gübûrâ, pele, niplä’ôt, Güdôlöt, and the like. Interestingly none of these correspond with the modern terms of miracle. \\nSecondly, I analyzed the text of Exodus 14 which narrates the Sea Event, one of the representative miracle stories in the Hebrew Bible. Referring to the achievements of historical critical studies on this text, I distinguished various motives and traditions inherent in the text, and attempted to grasp its core messages, revealed through their polyphonic voices. By and large two themes are found in Exodus 14. One is about God’s sovereignty. God is described as the one who freely exploits either the power of nature or supernatural force and smashes Pharaoh’s chariots and his whole army. The other is about God’s protection for his people and about proper response to it. Since the same God is the one who protects and supports the Israelites, they should fear and trust in him. These themes are repeated in the phrases which recount the Sea Event. By the way, scholars, who tend to acknowledge the historicity of the core substance of the story, accept the naturalistic explanation of the event from the text, while disregarding the supernatural descriptions of it as either a secondary source or a later embellishment. As a result, such attempts lead to neglecting some integral elements in the text. Their efforts to make believe the story, by eliminating supernatural and mythic components of the text, lead to miss the important themes that Exodus 14 conveys. \\nThird, it would be necessary to examine the ways in which the ancient Israelites perceived the world, history and nature in order to understand the miracle stories in the OT. They had not questioned the possibility of miracles. Instead, they took it for granted that God can intervene in nature and history at any time he needs since he is the Lord who governs his created world and the world keeps its integrity only with God’s support. \\nAncient Israelites’ understanding of miracles is closely connected with their belief that God is always working in the history of salvation. Biblical miracle stories were written down and transmitted for the purpose of strengthening and edifying their faith in God. In this sense, the story of the Sea Event in Exodus 14 had a great influence on the growth of their faith. Therefore, I suggest that a proper way to read the miracle stories in the OT is not to pose a question of whether the miracles that the text presents would be possible or not, but to ask what theological, heuristic, and ethical messages are conveyed through them.\",\"PeriodicalId\":370969,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"The Society of Theology and Thought\",\"volume\":\"28 \",\"pages\":\"0\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"2022-06-30\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"The Society of Theology and Thought\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.21731/ctat.2022.86.8\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"\",\"JCRName\":\"\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"The Society of Theology and Thought","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.21731/ctat.2022.86.8","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
这篇文章从旧约及其作者的角度提出了一个永恒的问题:奇迹是什么,奇迹是否真的会发生。它旨在澄清旧约(以下简称为OT)所描述的奇迹的定义,通过比较来检查它与现代奇迹定义的差异,并建议如何阅读和理解OT的奇迹故事。我们对奇迹的探究分三步进行。首先,我检查了旧约中各种奇迹术语的含义和词汇用法,以找出旧约的作者可能在他们心中保留的奇迹定义。代表奇迹的术语是“ôt, môpët, g b r,贝利,niplä”ôt, Güdôlöt,诸如此类。有趣的是,这些都不符合现代的奇迹术语。其次,我分析了《出埃及记》第14章的文本,其中叙述了希伯来圣经中具有代表性的神迹故事之一——海事件。在参考历史批判研究成果的基础上,我区分了文本内在的各种动机和传统,并试图把握其核心信息,通过它们的复调声音揭示出来。总的来说,出埃及记第14章有两个主题。一个是关于上帝的主权。神被描述为一个自由地利用自然或超自然力量的人,他摧毁了法老的战车和他的整个军队。另一个是关于上帝对他的子民的保护,以及适当的回应。因为保护和支持以色列人的是同一位上帝,他们应该敬畏和信任他。这些主题在叙述海上事件的短语中反复出现。顺便说一下,学者们倾向于承认故事核心内容的历史性,他们接受文本中对事件的自然主义解释,而忽略了超自然的描述,认为它要么是次要来源,要么是后来的点缀。结果,这种尝试导致忽视了文本中的一些整体要素。他们通过消除文本中超自然和神话的成分,努力使故事可信,导致错过了出埃及记第14章所传达的重要主题。第三,有必要考察古代以色列人感知世界、历史和自然的方式,以便理解旧约中的奇迹故事。他们没有怀疑奇迹的可能性。相反,他们理所当然地认为上帝可以在他需要的任何时候干预自然和历史,因为他是主宰他创造的世界的上帝,世界只有在上帝的支持下才能保持完整。古代以色列人对奇迹的理解与他们相信上帝总是在拯救的历史中工作密切相关。圣经中的神迹故事被记录下来并传播,目的是为了加强和培养他们对上帝的信心。从这个意义上说,出埃及记14章中的海上事件对他们信仰的成长有很大的影响。因此,我建议,阅读《旧约》中神迹故事的正确方法,不是提出文本所呈现的神迹是否可能的问题,而是要问这些神迹传达了什么样的神学、启发式和伦理信息。
A Study of Miracle Stories in the Old Testament, Focused on the Sea Event of Exodus 14
This article poses a perennial question of what miracles are and of whether miracles can really happen from the perspectives of the Old Testament and its authors. It aims to clarify the definition of miracles that the books of the Old Testament (to be abbreviated as OT hereafter) describe, to examine its differences from the modern definition of miracles by comparison, and to suggest how to read and understand the miracle stories of the OT.
Our inquiry about miracles proceeded in three steps. First, I examined the meanings and lexical usages of various terms for miracles in the OT to figure out the definition of miracles that the authors of the OT might have kept in their mind. The terms for miracles are ’ôt, môpët, Gübûrâ, pele, niplä’ôt, Güdôlöt, and the like. Interestingly none of these correspond with the modern terms of miracle.
Secondly, I analyzed the text of Exodus 14 which narrates the Sea Event, one of the representative miracle stories in the Hebrew Bible. Referring to the achievements of historical critical studies on this text, I distinguished various motives and traditions inherent in the text, and attempted to grasp its core messages, revealed through their polyphonic voices. By and large two themes are found in Exodus 14. One is about God’s sovereignty. God is described as the one who freely exploits either the power of nature or supernatural force and smashes Pharaoh’s chariots and his whole army. The other is about God’s protection for his people and about proper response to it. Since the same God is the one who protects and supports the Israelites, they should fear and trust in him. These themes are repeated in the phrases which recount the Sea Event. By the way, scholars, who tend to acknowledge the historicity of the core substance of the story, accept the naturalistic explanation of the event from the text, while disregarding the supernatural descriptions of it as either a secondary source or a later embellishment. As a result, such attempts lead to neglecting some integral elements in the text. Their efforts to make believe the story, by eliminating supernatural and mythic components of the text, lead to miss the important themes that Exodus 14 conveys.
Third, it would be necessary to examine the ways in which the ancient Israelites perceived the world, history and nature in order to understand the miracle stories in the OT. They had not questioned the possibility of miracles. Instead, they took it for granted that God can intervene in nature and history at any time he needs since he is the Lord who governs his created world and the world keeps its integrity only with God’s support.
Ancient Israelites’ understanding of miracles is closely connected with their belief that God is always working in the history of salvation. Biblical miracle stories were written down and transmitted for the purpose of strengthening and edifying their faith in God. In this sense, the story of the Sea Event in Exodus 14 had a great influence on the growth of their faith. Therefore, I suggest that a proper way to read the miracle stories in the OT is not to pose a question of whether the miracles that the text presents would be possible or not, but to ask what theological, heuristic, and ethical messages are conveyed through them.