Circumcision Stories: Enhancing our Understanding of Parental Perspectives in a Context of Controversy

Abstract: This commentary examines twelve stories in which parents recount how they (and often their co-parent) decided whether or not to circumcise their newborn sons. Several debated whether this should be their decision to make. The stories offer an intimate glimpse into people's efforts to do the best for children in a context of incomplete and changing information and intense public controversy. The commentary explores the diverse meanings and contradictory commonsense beliefs that surround foreskin removal in the United States today. Considering these parents' reflections—and their silences—can help us appreciate the real-life consequences of debates about the ethics of male circumcision.