Response to critics

ABSTRACTIn this piece I respond to the critiques raised by the contributors to this symposium.Keywords: Collective responsibilitycitizenshipintentional participation Disclosure statementNo potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).Notes1. In reality, shareholders are shielded from personal responsibility through the practice of limited corporate liability. Kutz rejects this practice and I share his concerns (Kutz, Citation2000, pp. 337–354).2. King (Citation2016) offers an important alternative to this account.Additional informationNotes on contributorsAvia PasternakAvia Pasternak is an associate professor at the Department of Philosophy, The University of Toronto. Her research focuses on questions of political philosophy and public affairs.