{"title":"明斯特共和国“真正的资本”的民政和经济禀赋,1922年7 - 8月","authors":"John Borgonovo","doi":"10.1353/eir.2023.a910478","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Civil Administration and Economic Endowments in the Munster Republic's \"Real Capital,\" July–August 1922 John Borgonovo (bio) The Irish Civil War opened with a six-week \"conventional phase\" during which the anti-Treaty Irish Republican Army (hereafter called the IRA) controlled most of the province of Munster, which historians often term the \"Munster Republic.\"1 This period ended when the National Army seized Cork city and the other major cities and towns in the province following simultaneous amphibious landings along the Cork coast. The IRA retreated into the hills and remote hinterland and thereafter controlled only a fraction of the province. Megan A. Stewart and Yu-Ming Liou have argued that \"territorial control is a tremendous military asset for insurgents, and such control should enhance any group's strength and latent capacity for violence (whether against civilians or the state).\"2 While the republican occupation of Cork city has been explored as the backdrop to the \"Battle for Cork,\" it typically receives only cursory mention in Irish Civil War studies, primarily as a curiosity rather than as a military center of [End Page 9] gravity for the anti-Treaty campaign.3 Yet republican-held Munster generally, and Cork city in particular, offered the anti-Treaty forces \"economic endowments,\" which Jeremy M. Weinstein has defined as \"resources that can be mobilized to finance the start-up and maintenance of a rebel organization.\"4 This article will explore how the IRA exploited economic endowments in Cork city. It will further identify republican attempts at civil administration within the city, discuss their challenges and shortcomings, and consider their implications during the republican campaign against the Irish Free State. Establishing the \"Munster Republic\" The Irish Civil War began with the National Army attack on the IRA's governing executive and general headquarters inside the Four Courts complex in Dublin. Situated outside the besieged Four Courts, Liam Lynch resumed the role of IRA chief of staff and returned to Munster to set up a new general headquarters and to mobilize and organize resistance to the Free State. Munster IRA units quickly captured pro-Treaty garrisons in Skibbereen and Listowel, consolidated their hold over the province, and advanced on Free State forces controlling Limerick city and west Limerick.5 Liam Lynch eventually set up a \"field headquarters\" and assembled a new headquarters staff in the extensive Fermoy Military Barracks in north Cork. Fighting the National Army along a rough line stretching from Limerick city to Waterford city during July, the IRA formed its \"field army\" comprised of numerous attached IRA flying columns and support units from various Munster brigades that probably numbered about three thousand full-time fighters.6 IRA brigades in counties Cork, Kerry, Waterford, and west Limerick reported to the First Southern Division, whose headquarters interacted directly with IRA general headquarters. The Cork No. 1 Brigade was the largest unit in the First [End Page 10] Southern Division and maintained its own headquarters in Cork city, which numbered about seventy-five thousand people and was the recognized commercial and communications center for Munster. Cork thereafter assumed its role as the unofficial or \"real capital\" (a contemporary nickname commonly used by city residents) of \"the Munster Republic\"—territory in the province controlled by the IRA during the first seven weeks of the Civil War. When it received word of the Four Courts attack, the Cork No. 1 Brigade leadership gathered in Cork city to determine whether to join the war. Despite the opposition of the brigade's dominant commanding officer Seán O'Hegarty, the IRA's Cork No. 1 Brigade entered the conflict on the republican side. (Ultimately, O'Hegarty and Brigade Adjutant Dominic Sullivan resigned from the IRA and took a neutral stance in the Civil War.)7 Operating from Cork city, the revised brigade leadership formed two large flying columns totaling about a hundred Volunteers and moved on Limerick city.8 Another republican column of about a hundred fighters was subsequently dispatched to Waterford. Lacking funds and supplies, Cork Volunteers equipped themselves through a frenzy of commandeering before departing for \"the front.\" They visited clothing shops to seize trench coats, leggings, and boots for flying-column fighters...","PeriodicalId":43507,"journal":{"name":"EIRE-IRELAND","volume":null,"pages":null},"PeriodicalIF":0.2000,"publicationDate":"2023-09-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Civil Administration and Economic Endowments in the Munster Republic's \\\"Real Capital,\\\" July–August 1922\",\"authors\":\"John Borgonovo\",\"doi\":\"10.1353/eir.2023.a910478\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"Civil Administration and Economic Endowments in the Munster Republic's \\\"Real Capital,\\\" July–August 1922 John Borgonovo (bio) The Irish Civil War opened with a six-week \\\"conventional phase\\\" during which the anti-Treaty Irish Republican Army (hereafter called the IRA) controlled most of the province of Munster, which historians often term the \\\"Munster Republic.\\\"1 This period ended when the National Army seized Cork city and the other major cities and towns in the province following simultaneous amphibious landings along the Cork coast. The IRA retreated into the hills and remote hinterland and thereafter controlled only a fraction of the province. Megan A. Stewart and Yu-Ming Liou have argued that \\\"territorial control is a tremendous military asset for insurgents, and such control should enhance any group's strength and latent capacity for violence (whether against civilians or the state).\\\"2 While the republican occupation of Cork city has been explored as the backdrop to the \\\"Battle for Cork,\\\" it typically receives only cursory mention in Irish Civil War studies, primarily as a curiosity rather than as a military center of [End Page 9] gravity for the anti-Treaty campaign.3 Yet republican-held Munster generally, and Cork city in particular, offered the anti-Treaty forces \\\"economic endowments,\\\" which Jeremy M. Weinstein has defined as \\\"resources that can be mobilized to finance the start-up and maintenance of a rebel organization.\\\"4 This article will explore how the IRA exploited economic endowments in Cork city. It will further identify republican attempts at civil administration within the city, discuss their challenges and shortcomings, and consider their implications during the republican campaign against the Irish Free State. Establishing the \\\"Munster Republic\\\" The Irish Civil War began with the National Army attack on the IRA's governing executive and general headquarters inside the Four Courts complex in Dublin. Situated outside the besieged Four Courts, Liam Lynch resumed the role of IRA chief of staff and returned to Munster to set up a new general headquarters and to mobilize and organize resistance to the Free State. Munster IRA units quickly captured pro-Treaty garrisons in Skibbereen and Listowel, consolidated their hold over the province, and advanced on Free State forces controlling Limerick city and west Limerick.5 Liam Lynch eventually set up a \\\"field headquarters\\\" and assembled a new headquarters staff in the extensive Fermoy Military Barracks in north Cork. Fighting the National Army along a rough line stretching from Limerick city to Waterford city during July, the IRA formed its \\\"field army\\\" comprised of numerous attached IRA flying columns and support units from various Munster brigades that probably numbered about three thousand full-time fighters.6 IRA brigades in counties Cork, Kerry, Waterford, and west Limerick reported to the First Southern Division, whose headquarters interacted directly with IRA general headquarters. The Cork No. 1 Brigade was the largest unit in the First [End Page 10] Southern Division and maintained its own headquarters in Cork city, which numbered about seventy-five thousand people and was the recognized commercial and communications center for Munster. Cork thereafter assumed its role as the unofficial or \\\"real capital\\\" (a contemporary nickname commonly used by city residents) of \\\"the Munster Republic\\\"—territory in the province controlled by the IRA during the first seven weeks of the Civil War. When it received word of the Four Courts attack, the Cork No. 1 Brigade leadership gathered in Cork city to determine whether to join the war. Despite the opposition of the brigade's dominant commanding officer Seán O'Hegarty, the IRA's Cork No. 1 Brigade entered the conflict on the republican side. (Ultimately, O'Hegarty and Brigade Adjutant Dominic Sullivan resigned from the IRA and took a neutral stance in the Civil War.)7 Operating from Cork city, the revised brigade leadership formed two large flying columns totaling about a hundred Volunteers and moved on Limerick city.8 Another republican column of about a hundred fighters was subsequently dispatched to Waterford. Lacking funds and supplies, Cork Volunteers equipped themselves through a frenzy of commandeering before departing for \\\"the front.\\\" They visited clothing shops to seize trench coats, leggings, and boots for flying-column fighters...\",\"PeriodicalId\":43507,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"EIRE-IRELAND\",\"volume\":null,\"pages\":null},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.2000,\"publicationDate\":\"2023-09-01\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"EIRE-IRELAND\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.1353/eir.2023.a910478\",\"RegionNum\":4,\"RegionCategory\":\"社会学\",\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"0\",\"JCRName\":\"HUMANITIES, MULTIDISCIPLINARY\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"EIRE-IRELAND","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1353/eir.2023.a910478","RegionNum":4,"RegionCategory":"社会学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"0","JCRName":"HUMANITIES, MULTIDISCIPLINARY","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
1922年7月至8月明斯特共和国“真正的首都”的民事管理和经济资助约翰·博尔戈诺沃(传记)爱尔兰内战开始于为期六周的“常规阶段”,在此期间,反条约的爱尔兰共和军(以下简称爱尔兰共和军)控制了明斯特省的大部分地区,历史学家通常将其称为“明斯特共和国”。这一时期结束时,国民军同时沿着科克海岸登陆,占领了科克市和该省其他主要城镇。爱尔兰共和军撤退到山区和偏远的腹地,此后只控制了该省的一小部分地区。梅根·a·斯图尔特(Megan a . Stewart)和刘玉明(Yu-Ming Liou)认为,“对领土的控制对叛乱分子来说是一项巨大的军事资产,这种控制应该增强任何组织的力量和潜在的暴力能力(无论是针对平民还是针对国家)。”虽然共和军对科克城的占领被作为“科克战役”的背景进行了探讨,但在爱尔兰内战研究中,它通常只被粗略地提及,主要是作为一种好奇心,而不是作为反条约运动的军事中心然而,共和党控制的明斯特,尤其是科克市,为反条约武装提供了“经济捐助”,杰里米·m·温斯坦(Jeremy M. Weinstein)将其定义为“可以动员起来为一个反叛组织的启动和维持提供资金的资源”。本文将探讨爱尔兰共和军如何利用科克市的经济禀赋。它将进一步确定共和派在城市内民政管理方面的尝试,讨论他们的挑战和缺点,并考虑他们在反对爱尔兰自由邦的共和派运动中的影响。建立“明斯特共和国”爱尔兰内战开始于国民军对爱尔兰共和军在都柏林四法院内的行政和总司令部的攻击。在被围困的四法院外,利亚姆·林奇恢复了爱尔兰共和军参谋长的角色,回到明斯特建立了一个新的总部,并动员和组织对自由邦的抵抗。明斯特共和军迅速占领了斯基伯林和利斯托维尔的亲条约驻军,巩固了他们对该省的控制,并向控制利默里克市和利默里克西部的自由邦军队推进。利亚姆·林奇最终建立了一个“战场总部”,并在科克北部广阔的费尔莫伊军营集结了新的总部人员。7月,爱尔兰共和军沿着一条从利默里克市一直延伸到沃特福德市的粗糙路线与国民军作战,共和军组建了自己的“野战军”,由许多附属的爱尔兰共和军飞行纵队和来自各个明斯特旅的支援部队组成,大约有3000名全职战士爱尔兰共和军在科克郡、克里郡、沃特福德郡和西利默里克郡的旅向南方第一师报告,该师的总部与爱尔兰共和军总部直接互动。科克第一旅是第一南师最大的部队,在科克市有自己的总部,科克市有大约7.5万人,是明斯特公认的商业和通讯中心。此后,科克成为了“明斯特共和国”(Munster Republic)的非官方或“真正的首都”(城市居民普遍使用的当代昵称)的角色。明斯特共和国是爱尔兰共和军在内战前七周控制的省份。当科克第一旅收到“四宫”进攻的消息后,他们聚集在科克城决定是否参战。尽管该旅的主要指挥官Seán O'Hegarty反对,爱尔兰共和军的科克第一旅还是加入了共和军一方的冲突。(最终,奥赫加蒂和旅部副官多米尼克·沙利文从爱尔兰共和军辞职,在内战中采取中立立场。)7从科克城出发,修改后的旅部领导组成了两支庞大的飞行纵队,总共约有100名志愿军,向利默里克城进发另一支共和军纵队约有一百名战士,随后被派往沃特福德。由于缺乏资金和物资,科克志愿者在出发前往“前线”之前,通过疯狂的征用来装备自己。他们到服装店去抢给飞行纵队战士穿的风衣、打底裤和靴子。
Civil Administration and Economic Endowments in the Munster Republic's "Real Capital," July–August 1922
Civil Administration and Economic Endowments in the Munster Republic's "Real Capital," July–August 1922 John Borgonovo (bio) The Irish Civil War opened with a six-week "conventional phase" during which the anti-Treaty Irish Republican Army (hereafter called the IRA) controlled most of the province of Munster, which historians often term the "Munster Republic."1 This period ended when the National Army seized Cork city and the other major cities and towns in the province following simultaneous amphibious landings along the Cork coast. The IRA retreated into the hills and remote hinterland and thereafter controlled only a fraction of the province. Megan A. Stewart and Yu-Ming Liou have argued that "territorial control is a tremendous military asset for insurgents, and such control should enhance any group's strength and latent capacity for violence (whether against civilians or the state)."2 While the republican occupation of Cork city has been explored as the backdrop to the "Battle for Cork," it typically receives only cursory mention in Irish Civil War studies, primarily as a curiosity rather than as a military center of [End Page 9] gravity for the anti-Treaty campaign.3 Yet republican-held Munster generally, and Cork city in particular, offered the anti-Treaty forces "economic endowments," which Jeremy M. Weinstein has defined as "resources that can be mobilized to finance the start-up and maintenance of a rebel organization."4 This article will explore how the IRA exploited economic endowments in Cork city. It will further identify republican attempts at civil administration within the city, discuss their challenges and shortcomings, and consider their implications during the republican campaign against the Irish Free State. Establishing the "Munster Republic" The Irish Civil War began with the National Army attack on the IRA's governing executive and general headquarters inside the Four Courts complex in Dublin. Situated outside the besieged Four Courts, Liam Lynch resumed the role of IRA chief of staff and returned to Munster to set up a new general headquarters and to mobilize and organize resistance to the Free State. Munster IRA units quickly captured pro-Treaty garrisons in Skibbereen and Listowel, consolidated their hold over the province, and advanced on Free State forces controlling Limerick city and west Limerick.5 Liam Lynch eventually set up a "field headquarters" and assembled a new headquarters staff in the extensive Fermoy Military Barracks in north Cork. Fighting the National Army along a rough line stretching from Limerick city to Waterford city during July, the IRA formed its "field army" comprised of numerous attached IRA flying columns and support units from various Munster brigades that probably numbered about three thousand full-time fighters.6 IRA brigades in counties Cork, Kerry, Waterford, and west Limerick reported to the First Southern Division, whose headquarters interacted directly with IRA general headquarters. The Cork No. 1 Brigade was the largest unit in the First [End Page 10] Southern Division and maintained its own headquarters in Cork city, which numbered about seventy-five thousand people and was the recognized commercial and communications center for Munster. Cork thereafter assumed its role as the unofficial or "real capital" (a contemporary nickname commonly used by city residents) of "the Munster Republic"—territory in the province controlled by the IRA during the first seven weeks of the Civil War. When it received word of the Four Courts attack, the Cork No. 1 Brigade leadership gathered in Cork city to determine whether to join the war. Despite the opposition of the brigade's dominant commanding officer Seán O'Hegarty, the IRA's Cork No. 1 Brigade entered the conflict on the republican side. (Ultimately, O'Hegarty and Brigade Adjutant Dominic Sullivan resigned from the IRA and took a neutral stance in the Civil War.)7 Operating from Cork city, the revised brigade leadership formed two large flying columns totaling about a hundred Volunteers and moved on Limerick city.8 Another republican column of about a hundred fighters was subsequently dispatched to Waterford. Lacking funds and supplies, Cork Volunteers equipped themselves through a frenzy of commandeering before departing for "the front." They visited clothing shops to seize trench coats, leggings, and boots for flying-column fighters...
期刊介绍:
An interdisciplinary scholarly journal of international repute, Éire Ireland is the leading forum in the flourishing field of Irish Studies. Since 1966, Éire-Ireland has published a wide range of imaginative work and scholarly articles from all areas of the arts, humanities, and social sciences relating to Ireland and Irish America.