Treadmill induced belt-accelerations may not accurately evoke the muscle responses to obstacle trips in older people

Background

Treadmill belt-accelerations are a commonly utilised surrogate for tripping, but their physiological validity is unknown. This study examined if a treadmill belt-acceleration induces lower limb muscle activation responses similar to a trip on a walkway.

Methods

38 older people (65+ years) experienced one treadmill belt-acceleration and one walkway obstacle trip in random order. Muscle responses were assessed bilaterally using surface electromyography on the rectus femoris (RF), tibialis anterior (TA), semitendinosus (ST) and gastrocnemius medial head (GM). Unperturbed muscle activity, post-perturbation onset latency, peak magnitude, time to peak and co-contraction index (CCI) were examined.

Results

Muscle activity in the right ST was greater during unperturbed walking on the treadmill compared to walkway (P=0.011). Compared to a treadmill belt-acceleration, a walkway trip elicited faster onset latencies in all muscles; greater peak magnitudes in the left RF, TA, GM and right GM; faster time to peaks in the left TA and right GM; and lower knee and ankle muscle CCI (P<0.05).

Conclusions

Walkway trips and treadmill belt-accelerations elicit distinct muscle activation patterns. While walkway trips induced faster and larger muscle responses, treadmill belt-accelerations involved greater co-contraction. Therefore, treadmill belt-accelerations may not accurately simulate the muscle responses to trips.