Optimizing measurements of linear changes of NMR signal parameters

Serial NMR experiments are commonly applied in variable-temperature studies, reaction monitoring, and other tasks. The resonance frequencies often shift linearly over the series, and the shift rates help to characterize the studied system. They can be determined using a classical fitting of peak positions or a more advanced method of Radon transform. However, the optimal procedure for data collection remains to be determined. In this paper, we discuss how to invest experimental time, i.e., whether to measure more scans at the expense of the number of spectra or vice versa. The results indicate that classical fitting provides slightly less error than the Radon transform, although the latter can be the method of choice for a low signal-to-noise ratio. We demonstrate this fact through theoretical consideration, simulations, and an experiment. Finally, we extend our considerations to the linear fitting of peak amplitudes. Interestingly, the optimal setup for measuring peak height changes differs from the one for resonance frequency changes — fewer spectra with more scans provide better results.