HPLC validation as a management tool in artificial water storage ponds

Pigment analysis through high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) offers a faster and more replicable study of the phytoplankton community structure than traditional taxonomy, but its application to small-sized freshwater ecosystems is infrequent. We carried out a taxonomy-based validation for the application of HPLC to the management of two artificial water storage ponds. We also investigated the error and variability sources that affected the relationships between calculated biovolumes of phytoplankton groups and associated pigment concentrations. For both qualitative and quantitative approaches, agreement was obtained between techniques that consistently identified biomass peaks and structural trophic differences between the ponds. Considering the most relevant pigment to biovolume ratios for total biomass, and partial biomass proxies of green algae and fucoxanthin containing algae, a decreasing tendency was obtained as total and partial biomass increased in all the studied models. Bidirectional variability affecting these relationships scaled under high biomass conditions and suggested a better suitability of HPLC application under oligotrophic conditions, which is in line with previous studies. Additionally, pigment data was able to identify mean stored volume as the main environmental factor that drove trophic differences between the ponds. We conclude that HPLC is accurate not just for monitoring purposes, but to carry out ecosystem-level assessments in artificial ponds. Therefore, we endorse the use of HPLC as part of the monitoring networks in small-sized freshwater ecosystems.