Classification and reconstructive algorithm for nasal alar defect in Asians

Background

The nasal alar defect in Asians remains a challenging issue, as do clear classification and algorithm guidance, despite numerous previously described surgical techniques. The aim of this study is to propose a surgical algorithm that addresses the appropriate surgical procedures for different types of nasal alar defects in Asian patients.

Methods

A retrospective case note review was conducted on 32 patients with nasal alar defect who underwent reconstruction between 2008 and 2022. Based on careful analysis and our clinical experience, we proposed a classification system for nasal alar defects and presented a reconstructive algorithm. Patient data, including age, sex, diagnosis, surgical options, and complications, were assessed. The extent of surgical scar formation was evaluated using standard photography based on a 4-grade scar scale.

Results

Among the 32 patients, there were 20 males and 12 females with nasal alar defects. The predominant cause of trauma in China was industrial factors. The majority of alar defects were classified as type I C (n=8, 25%), comprising 18 cases (56.2%); there were 5 cases (15.6%) of type II defect, 7 (21.9%) of type III defect, and 2 (6.3%) of type IV defect. The most common surgical option was auricular composite graft (n=8, 25%), followed by bilobed flap (n=6, 18.8%), free auricular composite flap (n=4, 12.5%), and primary closure (n=3, 9.4%). Satisfactory improvements were observed postoperatively.

Conclusion

Factors contributing to classifications were analyzed and defined, providing a framework for the proposed classification system. The reconstructive algorithm offers surgeons appropriate procedures for treating nasal alar defect in Asians.