Sulfur cycling likely obscures dynamic biologically-driven iron redox cycling in contemporary methane seep environments

Deep-sea methane seeps are amongst the most biologically productive environments on Earth and are often characterised by stable, low oxygen concentrations and microbial communities that couple the anaerobic oxidation of methane to sulfate reduction or iron reduction in the underlying sediment. At these sites, ferrous iron (Fe²⁺) can be produced by organoclastic iron reduction, methanotrophic-coupled iron reduction, or through the abiotic reduction by sulfide produced by the abundant sulfate-reducing bacteria at these sites. The prevalence of Fe²⁺in the anoxic sediments, as well as the availability of oxygen in the overlying water, suggests that seeps could also harbour communities of iron-oxidising microbes. However, it is unclear to what extent Fe²⁺ remains bioavailable and in solution given that the abiotic reaction between sulfide and ferrous iron is often assumed to scavenge all ferrous iron as insoluble iron sulfides and pyrite. Accordingly, we searched the sea floor at methane seeps along the Cascadia Margin for microaerobic, neutrophilic iron-oxidising bacteria, operating under the reasoning that if iron-oxidising bacteria could be isolated from these environments, it could indicate that porewater Fe²⁺ can persist is long enough for biology to outcompete pyritisation. We found that the presence of sulfate in our enrichment media muted any obvious microbially-driven iron oxidation with most iron being precipitated as iron sulfides. Transfer of enrichment cultures to sulfate-depleted media led to dynamic iron redox cycling relative to abiotic controls and sulfate-containing cultures, and demonstrated the capacity for biogenic iron (oxyhydr)oxides from a methane seep-derived community. 16S rRNA analyses revealed that removing sulfate drastically reduced the diversity of enrichment cultures and caused a general shift from a Gammaproteobacteria-domainated ecosystem to one dominated by Rhodobacteraceae (Alphaproteobacteria). Our data suggest that, in most cases, sulfur cycling may restrict the biological “ferrous wheel” in contemporary environments through a combination of the sulfur-adapted sediment-dwelling ecosystems and the abiotic reactions they influence.