Measure to improve: a pilot study of Birthrate Plus in the Netherlands

Evidence-based standards are an important means for ensuring safe and effective care for birthing women. The provision of one-to-one care for women in labour is one such standard, which should be the norm in Dutch maternity care. However, no audit measures of this standard are available. This study examined the use of Birthrate Plus, a validated instrument for the measurement of patient acuity. This tool has the added benefit of allowing measurement of birth characteristics in relation to staffing numbers, providing a basis for auditing the standard of one-to-one care for women in labour in hospitals in the Netherlands. This pilot study used the Birthrate Plus tool to retrospectively examine birth characteristics and staffing levels in a 4-month period, in five hospitals in the Netherlands. The review of 11 582 patient cases found that most births in the sample were classified as occurring in the higher acuity levels of Birthrate+ tool. Examination of staffing levels showed that when comparing actual staffing levels with recommended levels, hospitals had a shortfall of between 47% and 64%. The Birthrate Plus tool could be useful in auditing staffing levels in Dutch maternity care. Analysis of the data provided by hospitals in the sample showed that none were able to meet the Dutch standard of providing consistent one-one-one care.