Children’s and mothers’ understanding of play and learning: Repertoires across five cultures

Background

Multiple tensions pervade the relationship between play and learning. Children's perceptions of this relationship are rarely analysed or placed alongside their parents' views. Literature has focused on predominant themes ignoring intra and inter-cultural variability.

Aims

We aimed to capture the different ways in which children and mothers in different cultural contexts conceive children's daily activities as instances of play and of learning.

Samples

Participants were 392 children (aged 5 and 7) and 192 mothers from Argentina, Denmark, China, England, United States.

Methods

Through a semi-structured interview, two closing questions were analysed: ‘Do you think it's possible to play and learn at the same time? Playing and learning, what's the difference between them?‘Lexicometry was applied to participants' responses. Qualitative analysis of local results was carried out to build a cross-cultural repertoire.

Results

A wide range of understandings emerged ranging from an impossibility of co-occurrence (characteristic of children) to a beneficial co-occurrence (characteristic of mothers). For many children play and learning constitute separate realms of activity and only among children is there evidence that learning is necessary to play. For all mothers, daily activities are opportunities for learning. Intra age-group heterogeneity varied across sites.

Conclusions

Learning in play was conceived by the children, but play in learning was restricted to academic learning. Hegemonic conceptions of education influenced participants' perceptions. The mothers expressed discrepancies between ‘ideal’ situations of co-occurrence between play and learning, and daily situations of not co-occurrence. A deep understanding of the synergies between these practices can unlock their mutual enrichment.