PmrB Y358N, E123D amino acid substitutions are not associated with colistin resistance but with phylogeny in Escherichia coli.

Colistin resistance in Escherichia coli is of public health significance for its use to treat multidrug-resistant Gram-negative infections. Amino acid variations in PmrB have been implicated in colistin resistance in E. coli. In this cross-sectional study, 288 generic E. coli isolates from surveillance of broiler chicken and feedlot cattle feces, retail meat, wastewater, and well water were whole-genome sequenced. Phylogroup designation and screening for two amino acid substitutions in PmrB putatively linked to colistin resistance (Y358N, E123D) were performed in silico. Three additional data sets of publicly available E. coli assemblies were similarly scrutinized: (i) E. coli isolates from studies identifying the Y358N or E123D substitutions, (ii) colistin-susceptible E. coli isolates reported in the literature, and (iii) a random sampling of 14,700 E. coli assemblies available in the National Center for Biotechnology Information public database. Within all data sets, ≥95% of phylogroup B1 and C isolates have the PmrB Y358N variation. The PmrB E123D amino acid substitution was only identified in phylogroup B2 isolates, of which 94%-100% demonstrate the substitution. Both PmrB amino acid variations were infrequent in other phylogroups. Among published colistin susceptible isolates, colistin minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs) were not higher in isolates bearing the E123D and Y358N amino acid variations than in isolates without these PmrB substitutions. The E123D and Y358N PmrB amino acid substitutions in E. coli appear strongly associated with phylogroup. The previously observed associations between Y358N and E123D amino acid substitutions in PmrB and colistin resistance in E. coli may be spurious.

Importance: Colistin is a critical last-resort treatment for extensively drug-resistant Gram-negative infections in humans. Therefore, accurate identification of the genetic mechanisms of resistance to this antimicrobial is crucial to effectively monitor and mitigate the spread of resistance. Examining over 16,000 whole-genome sequenced Escherichia coli isolates, this study identifies that PmrB E123D and Y358N amino acid substitutions previously associated with colistin resistance in E. coli are strongly associated with phylogroup and are alone not sufficient to confer a colistin-resistant phenotype. This is a critical clarification, as both substitutions are identified as putative mechanisms of colistin resistance in many publications and a common bioinformatic tool. Given the potential spurious nature of initial associations of these substitutions with colistin resistance, this study's findings emphasize the importance of appropriate experimental design and consideration of relevant biological factors such as phylogroup when ascribing causal mechanisms of resistance to chromosomal variations.