Previous Hip or Knee Arthroplasty is Associated With Less Favorable Patient-reported Outcomes of Lumbar Surgery.

Study design: Review of cohort studies.

Objective: To ascertain if previous hip (THA) or knee (TKA) arthroplasty was associated with patients' outcomes assessments of subsequent lumbar surgery, specifically overall satisfaction, less disability due to pain, and an affective appraisal reflecting emotional assessment of results.

Background: Hip, knee, and lumbar symptoms often co-exist and increasingly are managed with surgery. Whether previous total joint arthroplasty (TJA) impacts patients' perspectives of results of subsequent lumbar surgery is not known.

Methods: Identical and systematically acquired preoperative and postoperative data from 3 studies assessing psychosocial characteristics and outcomes of lumbar surgery were pooled. Data obtained during interviews included preoperative demographic and clinical variables and 2-year postoperative global overall assessment (very satisfied/satisfied, neither, dissatisfied/very dissatisfied) and global affective assessment (delighted/pleased, mostly satisfied/mixed/mostly dissatisfied, unhappy/terrible). Patients completed the ODI and preoperative to postoperative change was analyzed according to an MCID (15 points). At 2 years patients also reported any untoward events since surgery (ie, fracture, infection, or repeat lumbar surgery). Associations with outcomes were assessed with multivariable logistic ordinal regression controlling for untoward events. Type of arthroplasty was evaluated in subanalyses.

Results: Among 1227 patients (mean: 59 y, 50% women), 12% had arthroplasty (+TJA) and 88% did not (-TJA). In multivariable analysis, +TJA was associated with less global satisfaction (OR: 1.9, CI: 1.3-2.7, P=0.0007), worse global affective assessment (OR: 1.6, CI: 1.1-2.2, P=0.009), and not meeting MCID15 (OR: 1.5, CI: 1.0-2.3, P=0.05). Covariables associated with less favorable outcomes were not working, positive depression screen, and prior lumbar surgery. Compared with -TJA, patients with THA had worse affective assessments and patients with TKA had less satisfaction and were less likely to meet MCID15.

Conclusions: Previous hip or knee arthroplasty was associated with less favorable patient-reported outcomes of lumbar surgery. Surgeons and patients should discuss differences between procedures preoperatively and during shared postoperative outcome assessment.

Level of evidence: Level II.