Radiation damage study of POCO ZXF-5Q graphite for neutrino production targets using 4.5 MeV helium ions

To address the challenges of increased beam power and target survivability associated with next-generation particle production beam lines, high dose, high-energy proton beam conditions are simulated using irradiation from low-energy ion beams. A low-energy ion irradiation study of POCO ZXF-5Q graphite under conditions similar to those of the NuMI NT-02 neutrino production target at the Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory is reported. Helium ion irradiation was performed at ${100}^{\circ }\text{ C}$ to a maximum damage level of 0.9 displacements per atom (DPA). Irradiation induced hardening, swelling of the irradiated region, inter-plane lattice expansion, and intraplane lattice contraction with increasing ion fluence was observed using micromechanical (nanoindentation, atomic force microscopy) and electron microscopy (high-resolution imaging, selected area diffraction) characterization. Similar changes were also observed in post irradiation examination of the NT-02 target indicating that ion irradiation can be a valuable tool for estimating radiation damage in proton beam targets. Caution must be exercised though, because the hardening, lattice alteration, and swelling occur to different magnitudes for a given damage level. The observed hardening and embrittlement were greater for ion irradiated graphite. For He ion irradiated samples the lattice spacing changes were smaller at low damage levels (78% less expansion and 71% less contraction at 0.1 DPA) and larger at high damage levels (38% more expansion and 5% more contraction at 0.9 DPA) relative to that observed in the NT-02 target. The magnitude of swelling was 8.5× greater under ion irradiation which is influenced by the differing damage gradients and inclusion of implanted He ions in the region of interest.