书评

IF 2.6 Q2 Agricultural and Biological Sciences Copeia Pub Date : 2020-07-16 DOI:10.1643/CT2020012
W. Selman, K. Conway
{"title":"书评","authors":"W. Selman, K. Conway","doi":"10.1643/CT2020012","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Ecology and Conservation of the Diamond-backed Terrapin. W. M. Roosenburg and V. S. Kennedy (Eds.). 2018. Johns Hopkins University Press. ISBN 9781421426266. 277 p. $79.95 (hardcover).—The Diamond-backed Terrapin (Malaclemys terrapin) is not a freshwater turtle, and it is not a sea turtle. Truly a one-of-a-kind, the Diamond-backed Terrapin (hereafter, terrapin) is a brackish-water species that occupies a narrow strip of habitat along the Gulf of Mexico in the southern USA and Atlantic coastlines of the eastern USA, with an isolated population on the island of Bermuda. Along with being a habitat specialist, terrapins also have a colorful history and connection to people in the United States. Historically, this species was at the center of a culinary fad of the early 1900s for terrapin soup, while it is contemporarily connected with the coastal crab fisheries, where it is commonly taken as bycatch. The editors of the book, Willem Roosenburg and Vic Kennedy, are likely two of the best to tell this unique story, and they assembled 36 subject-area experts to craft 19 chapters about the species. Roosenburg has spent his career studying many aspects of the lives of terrapins, with his focusing on the status of populations in the Chesapeake Bay (a large estuary in the mid-Atlantic region of the northeastern USA bordered by the states of Maryland and Virginia), the impact of crab fisheries on terrapins, and the role of habitat restoration on species recovery. Kennedy has been vital to understanding the historical environment of the Chesapeake Bay and its fishery. Chapter 1, Introduction and History, provides an outline to the different sections of the book and introduces the reader to interesting aspects of the biology and ecology of terrapins. The author also poses some interesting questions for the reader to consider (e.g., if terrapins naturally dispersed to Bermuda, why aren’t they in Cuba? How did terrapins become one of the few tetrapods to inhabit brackish marshes?). Following the introduction, Part 1 of the book (Chapters 2–12) focuses on the Biology and Ecology of terrapins. Chapter 2 takes the reader through the numerous ways a researcher might capture, mark, and measure terrapins, while also providing methods for those who want to study their population and reproductive biology. This chapter also introduces other methods (e.g., molecular biology, tracking methods). While I appreciate the inclusion of this chapter and the myriad of ways to capture and study the species, it was an unexpected topic to start the book given the aforementioned colorful history of the species. In fact, this great history is not shared with the reader until Chapter 13, well after all the biology of the species is discussed. This is one organizational challenge I found with the book, and I will describe others later. The next three chapters detail the Evolutionary History and Paleontological Record (Chapter 3), Taxonomy (Chapter 4), and Molecular Ecology and Phylogeography (Chapter 5) of the species. The authors make some interesting points in Chapter 3, especially the idea that the paleontological history and record of terrapins is yet to be told. Because Neogene emydids are highly understudied paleontologically, it is likely that fossil material of terrapins already exists in collections and is waiting to be identified. Chapter 4 explains the taxonomic status of this species with regard to other emydids, the historical description of the seven terrapin subspecies, and the provenance and taxonomy of the terrapins recently described in Bermuda (Davenport et al., 2005). Fossil evidence and radiometric analysis indicates that terrapins on Bermuda are a native species and were present on the island prior to human settlement (i.e., pre-dating human transport from the mainland United States; Parham et al., 2008). This chapter also describes the molecular ecology of the species (e.g., genetic differences among populations), even though the Molecular Ecology chapter (5) follows it. Because taxonomy and genetics are now intimately connected, the editors should have opted for a single integrated chapter reviewing both traditional taxonomy and modern genetics. The most important story explained by the authors in both chapters is that our understanding of terrapin taxonomy has changed dramatically over the last 50–60 years. Historically, it appears that the species was subdivided into more subspecies (seven including the nominate form) than is supported by recent molecular work, which recognizes only four genetic groupings: northeastern Atlantic, coastal mid-Atlantic, Florida, and Louisiana/ Texas (Hart et al., 2014). Although these chapters contain great information written by incredible scientists, there is considerable overlap and duplication of material. Furthermore, the authors of Chapter 5 (Molecular Ecology and Phylogeography) assume the reader is familiar with genetic techniques, acronyms, and definitions and many of these were not defined (e.g., FST, HO, Bayesian Skyline Plots), leaving this chapter less accessible to the average reader. Chapter 6 (Life History with Emphasis on Geographic Variation) is a meta-analysis of life-history traits collected throughout the terrapin’s range, specifically metrics like adult male and female body size, mean clutch size, survivorship, etc. This chapter was written like a research article, with novel information about terrapins. This contrasts with the other chapters, which were primarily reviews of specific topics. Nonetheless, the authors offer distinct conclusions regarding the variation of life-history traits along latitudinal gradients. Examples include the finding of no relationship between male or female body size and latitude (i.e., the species does not conform to Bergmann’s rule) and that females produce larger clutches of smaller eggs at higher latitudes. A key addition of this chapter was the inclusion of a Future Research Needs section, where the authors suggest interesting studies for future researchers; this section also appears in most chapters of the book. I found this refreshing because this","PeriodicalId":10701,"journal":{"name":"Copeia","volume":null,"pages":null},"PeriodicalIF":2.6000,"publicationDate":"2020-07-16","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"BOOK REVIEWS\",\"authors\":\"W. Selman, K. Conway\",\"doi\":\"10.1643/CT2020012\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"Ecology and Conservation of the Diamond-backed Terrapin. W. M. Roosenburg and V. S. Kennedy (Eds.). 2018. Johns Hopkins University Press. ISBN 9781421426266. 277 p. $79.95 (hardcover).—The Diamond-backed Terrapin (Malaclemys terrapin) is not a freshwater turtle, and it is not a sea turtle. Truly a one-of-a-kind, the Diamond-backed Terrapin (hereafter, terrapin) is a brackish-water species that occupies a narrow strip of habitat along the Gulf of Mexico in the southern USA and Atlantic coastlines of the eastern USA, with an isolated population on the island of Bermuda. Along with being a habitat specialist, terrapins also have a colorful history and connection to people in the United States. Historically, this species was at the center of a culinary fad of the early 1900s for terrapin soup, while it is contemporarily connected with the coastal crab fisheries, where it is commonly taken as bycatch. The editors of the book, Willem Roosenburg and Vic Kennedy, are likely two of the best to tell this unique story, and they assembled 36 subject-area experts to craft 19 chapters about the species. Roosenburg has spent his career studying many aspects of the lives of terrapins, with his focusing on the status of populations in the Chesapeake Bay (a large estuary in the mid-Atlantic region of the northeastern USA bordered by the states of Maryland and Virginia), the impact of crab fisheries on terrapins, and the role of habitat restoration on species recovery. Kennedy has been vital to understanding the historical environment of the Chesapeake Bay and its fishery. Chapter 1, Introduction and History, provides an outline to the different sections of the book and introduces the reader to interesting aspects of the biology and ecology of terrapins. The author also poses some interesting questions for the reader to consider (e.g., if terrapins naturally dispersed to Bermuda, why aren’t they in Cuba? How did terrapins become one of the few tetrapods to inhabit brackish marshes?). Following the introduction, Part 1 of the book (Chapters 2–12) focuses on the Biology and Ecology of terrapins. Chapter 2 takes the reader through the numerous ways a researcher might capture, mark, and measure terrapins, while also providing methods for those who want to study their population and reproductive biology. This chapter also introduces other methods (e.g., molecular biology, tracking methods). While I appreciate the inclusion of this chapter and the myriad of ways to capture and study the species, it was an unexpected topic to start the book given the aforementioned colorful history of the species. In fact, this great history is not shared with the reader until Chapter 13, well after all the biology of the species is discussed. This is one organizational challenge I found with the book, and I will describe others later. The next three chapters detail the Evolutionary History and Paleontological Record (Chapter 3), Taxonomy (Chapter 4), and Molecular Ecology and Phylogeography (Chapter 5) of the species. The authors make some interesting points in Chapter 3, especially the idea that the paleontological history and record of terrapins is yet to be told. Because Neogene emydids are highly understudied paleontologically, it is likely that fossil material of terrapins already exists in collections and is waiting to be identified. Chapter 4 explains the taxonomic status of this species with regard to other emydids, the historical description of the seven terrapin subspecies, and the provenance and taxonomy of the terrapins recently described in Bermuda (Davenport et al., 2005). Fossil evidence and radiometric analysis indicates that terrapins on Bermuda are a native species and were present on the island prior to human settlement (i.e., pre-dating human transport from the mainland United States; Parham et al., 2008). This chapter also describes the molecular ecology of the species (e.g., genetic differences among populations), even though the Molecular Ecology chapter (5) follows it. Because taxonomy and genetics are now intimately connected, the editors should have opted for a single integrated chapter reviewing both traditional taxonomy and modern genetics. The most important story explained by the authors in both chapters is that our understanding of terrapin taxonomy has changed dramatically over the last 50–60 years. Historically, it appears that the species was subdivided into more subspecies (seven including the nominate form) than is supported by recent molecular work, which recognizes only four genetic groupings: northeastern Atlantic, coastal mid-Atlantic, Florida, and Louisiana/ Texas (Hart et al., 2014). Although these chapters contain great information written by incredible scientists, there is considerable overlap and duplication of material. Furthermore, the authors of Chapter 5 (Molecular Ecology and Phylogeography) assume the reader is familiar with genetic techniques, acronyms, and definitions and many of these were not defined (e.g., FST, HO, Bayesian Skyline Plots), leaving this chapter less accessible to the average reader. Chapter 6 (Life History with Emphasis on Geographic Variation) is a meta-analysis of life-history traits collected throughout the terrapin’s range, specifically metrics like adult male and female body size, mean clutch size, survivorship, etc. This chapter was written like a research article, with novel information about terrapins. This contrasts with the other chapters, which were primarily reviews of specific topics. Nonetheless, the authors offer distinct conclusions regarding the variation of life-history traits along latitudinal gradients. Examples include the finding of no relationship between male or female body size and latitude (i.e., the species does not conform to Bergmann’s rule) and that females produce larger clutches of smaller eggs at higher latitudes. A key addition of this chapter was the inclusion of a Future Research Needs section, where the authors suggest interesting studies for future researchers; this section also appears in most chapters of the book. I found this refreshing because this\",\"PeriodicalId\":10701,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Copeia\",\"volume\":null,\"pages\":null},\"PeriodicalIF\":2.6000,\"publicationDate\":\"2020-07-16\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Copeia\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.1643/CT2020012\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"Q2\",\"JCRName\":\"Agricultural and Biological Sciences\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Copeia","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1643/CT2020012","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q2","JCRName":"Agricultural and Biological Sciences","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0

摘要

钻石背Terrapin的生态与保护。W.M.Roosenburg和V.S.Kennedy(编辑),2018。约翰·霍普金斯大学出版社。是9781421426266。277页79.95美元(精装本)--钻石背水龟(Malalemys terrpin)不是淡水龟,也不是海龟。钻石背Terrapin(以下简称Terrapin)是一种半咸水物种,在美国南部的墨西哥湾和美国东部的大西洋海岸线占据了一条狭窄的栖息地,在百慕大岛上有一个孤立的种群。作为一名栖息地专家,水龟也有着丰富多彩的历史和与美国人民的联系。从历史上看,该物种是20世纪初水龟汤烹饪时尚的中心,而在当代,它与沿海螃蟹渔业有关,在那里它通常被视为副渔获物。这本书的编辑Willem Roosenburg和Vic Kennedy可能是讲述这个独特故事的两位最佳编辑,他们召集了36位主题领域专家,编写了19章关于该物种的章节。Roosenburg的职业生涯研究了水龟生活的许多方面,重点研究了切萨皮克湾(美国东北部大西洋中部的一个大河口,与马里兰州和弗吉尼亚州接壤)的种群状况、螃蟹捕捞对水龟的影响,以及栖息地恢复对物种恢复的作用。肯尼迪对了解切萨皮克湾及其渔业的历史环境至关重要。第一章,引言和历史,概述了本书的不同部分,并向读者介绍了水龟生物学和生态学的有趣方面。作者还提出了一些有趣的问题供读者考虑(例如,如果水龟自然分散到百慕大,为什么它们不在古巴?水龟是如何成为少数栖息在半咸水沼泽中的四足动物之一的?)。在引言之后,本书的第一部分(第2-12章)重点介绍了水龟的生物学和生态学。第2章带读者了解研究人员捕捉、标记和测量水龟的多种方法,同时也为那些想研究水龟种群和生殖生物学的人提供了方法。本章还介绍了其他方法(如分子生物学、追踪方法)。虽然我很欣赏这一章的内容以及捕捉和研究该物种的无数方法,但鉴于上述丰富多彩的物种历史,这本书的开头是一个意想不到的话题。事实上,直到第13章,在讨论了所有物种的生物学之后,这段伟大的历史才与读者分享。这是我在书中发现的一个组织挑战,我稍后将描述其他挑战。接下来的三章详细介绍了该物种的进化史和古生物学记录(第3章)、分类学(第4章)以及分子生态学和系统地理学(第5章)。作者在第三章中提出了一些有趣的观点,特别是关于水龟的古生物学历史和记录尚待说明的观点。由于上第三纪的蝾螈在古生物学上研究不足,水龟的化石材料很可能已经存在于收藏品中,正在等待鉴定。第4章解释了该物种相对于其他水龟的分类地位,七个水龟亚种的历史描述,以及最近在百慕大描述的水龟的来源和分类(Davenport et al.,2005)。化石证据和辐射分析表明,百慕大的水龟是一种本土物种,在人类定居之前就已经存在于该岛上(即,早于人类从美国大陆迁移的年代;Parham等人,2008年)。本章还描述了物种的分子生态学(例如,种群之间的遗传差异),尽管分子生态学第(5)章紧随其后。由于分类学和遗传学现在紧密相连,编辑们应该选择一个完整的章节来回顾传统分类学和现代遗传学。作者在这两章中解释的最重要的故事是,在过去的50-60年里,我们对水龟分类学的理解发生了巨大的变化。从历史上看,该物种似乎被细分为比最近的分子研究所支持的更多的亚种(包括提名形式在内的七个),最近的分子工作只识别了四个基因组:东北大西洋、大西洋中部沿海、佛罗里达州和路易斯安那州/得克萨斯州(Hart等人,2014)。尽管这些章节包含了由不可思议的科学家撰写的大量信息,但材料有相当多的重叠和重复。
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。
查看原文
分享 分享
微信好友 朋友圈 QQ好友 复制链接
本刊更多论文
BOOK REVIEWS
Ecology and Conservation of the Diamond-backed Terrapin. W. M. Roosenburg and V. S. Kennedy (Eds.). 2018. Johns Hopkins University Press. ISBN 9781421426266. 277 p. $79.95 (hardcover).—The Diamond-backed Terrapin (Malaclemys terrapin) is not a freshwater turtle, and it is not a sea turtle. Truly a one-of-a-kind, the Diamond-backed Terrapin (hereafter, terrapin) is a brackish-water species that occupies a narrow strip of habitat along the Gulf of Mexico in the southern USA and Atlantic coastlines of the eastern USA, with an isolated population on the island of Bermuda. Along with being a habitat specialist, terrapins also have a colorful history and connection to people in the United States. Historically, this species was at the center of a culinary fad of the early 1900s for terrapin soup, while it is contemporarily connected with the coastal crab fisheries, where it is commonly taken as bycatch. The editors of the book, Willem Roosenburg and Vic Kennedy, are likely two of the best to tell this unique story, and they assembled 36 subject-area experts to craft 19 chapters about the species. Roosenburg has spent his career studying many aspects of the lives of terrapins, with his focusing on the status of populations in the Chesapeake Bay (a large estuary in the mid-Atlantic region of the northeastern USA bordered by the states of Maryland and Virginia), the impact of crab fisheries on terrapins, and the role of habitat restoration on species recovery. Kennedy has been vital to understanding the historical environment of the Chesapeake Bay and its fishery. Chapter 1, Introduction and History, provides an outline to the different sections of the book and introduces the reader to interesting aspects of the biology and ecology of terrapins. The author also poses some interesting questions for the reader to consider (e.g., if terrapins naturally dispersed to Bermuda, why aren’t they in Cuba? How did terrapins become one of the few tetrapods to inhabit brackish marshes?). Following the introduction, Part 1 of the book (Chapters 2–12) focuses on the Biology and Ecology of terrapins. Chapter 2 takes the reader through the numerous ways a researcher might capture, mark, and measure terrapins, while also providing methods for those who want to study their population and reproductive biology. This chapter also introduces other methods (e.g., molecular biology, tracking methods). While I appreciate the inclusion of this chapter and the myriad of ways to capture and study the species, it was an unexpected topic to start the book given the aforementioned colorful history of the species. In fact, this great history is not shared with the reader until Chapter 13, well after all the biology of the species is discussed. This is one organizational challenge I found with the book, and I will describe others later. The next three chapters detail the Evolutionary History and Paleontological Record (Chapter 3), Taxonomy (Chapter 4), and Molecular Ecology and Phylogeography (Chapter 5) of the species. The authors make some interesting points in Chapter 3, especially the idea that the paleontological history and record of terrapins is yet to be told. Because Neogene emydids are highly understudied paleontologically, it is likely that fossil material of terrapins already exists in collections and is waiting to be identified. Chapter 4 explains the taxonomic status of this species with regard to other emydids, the historical description of the seven terrapin subspecies, and the provenance and taxonomy of the terrapins recently described in Bermuda (Davenport et al., 2005). Fossil evidence and radiometric analysis indicates that terrapins on Bermuda are a native species and were present on the island prior to human settlement (i.e., pre-dating human transport from the mainland United States; Parham et al., 2008). This chapter also describes the molecular ecology of the species (e.g., genetic differences among populations), even though the Molecular Ecology chapter (5) follows it. Because taxonomy and genetics are now intimately connected, the editors should have opted for a single integrated chapter reviewing both traditional taxonomy and modern genetics. The most important story explained by the authors in both chapters is that our understanding of terrapin taxonomy has changed dramatically over the last 50–60 years. Historically, it appears that the species was subdivided into more subspecies (seven including the nominate form) than is supported by recent molecular work, which recognizes only four genetic groupings: northeastern Atlantic, coastal mid-Atlantic, Florida, and Louisiana/ Texas (Hart et al., 2014). Although these chapters contain great information written by incredible scientists, there is considerable overlap and duplication of material. Furthermore, the authors of Chapter 5 (Molecular Ecology and Phylogeography) assume the reader is familiar with genetic techniques, acronyms, and definitions and many of these were not defined (e.g., FST, HO, Bayesian Skyline Plots), leaving this chapter less accessible to the average reader. Chapter 6 (Life History with Emphasis on Geographic Variation) is a meta-analysis of life-history traits collected throughout the terrapin’s range, specifically metrics like adult male and female body size, mean clutch size, survivorship, etc. This chapter was written like a research article, with novel information about terrapins. This contrasts with the other chapters, which were primarily reviews of specific topics. Nonetheless, the authors offer distinct conclusions regarding the variation of life-history traits along latitudinal gradients. Examples include the finding of no relationship between male or female body size and latitude (i.e., the species does not conform to Bergmann’s rule) and that females produce larger clutches of smaller eggs at higher latitudes. A key addition of this chapter was the inclusion of a Future Research Needs section, where the authors suggest interesting studies for future researchers; this section also appears in most chapters of the book. I found this refreshing because this
求助全文
通过发布文献求助,成功后即可免费获取论文全文。 去求助
来源期刊
Copeia
Copeia 生物-动物学
CiteScore
2.10
自引率
0.00%
发文量
0
审稿时长
6-12 weeks
期刊介绍: Founded in 1913, Copeia is a highly respected international journal dedicated to the publication of high quality, original research papers on the behavior, conservation, ecology, genetics, morphology, evolution, physiology, systematics and taxonomy of extant and extinct fishes, amphibians, and reptiles. Copeia is published electronically and is available through BioOne. Articles are published online first, and print issues appear four times per year. In addition to research articles, Copeia publishes invited review papers, book reviews, and compiles virtual issues on topics of interest drawn from papers previously published in the journal.
期刊最新文献
Summary of the Meetings Taxonomic Index Summary Of The Meetings Taxonomic Index EDITORIAL NOTES AND NEWS
×
引用
GB/T 7714-2015
复制
MLA
复制
APA
复制
导出至
BibTeX EndNote RefMan NoteFirst NoteExpress
×
×
提示
您的信息不完整,为了账户安全,请先补充。
现在去补充
×
提示
您因"违规操作"
具体请查看互助需知
我知道了
×
提示
现在去查看 取消
×
提示
确定
0
微信
客服QQ
Book学术公众号 扫码关注我们
反馈
×
意见反馈
请填写您的意见或建议
请填写您的手机或邮箱
已复制链接
已复制链接
快去分享给好友吧!
我知道了
×
扫码分享
扫码分享
Book学术官方微信
Book学术文献互助
Book学术文献互助群
群 号:481959085
Book学术
文献互助 智能选刊 最新文献 互助须知 联系我们:info@booksci.cn
Book学术提供免费学术资源搜索服务,方便国内外学者检索中英文文献。致力于提供最便捷和优质的服务体验。
Copyright © 2023 Book学术 All rights reserved.
ghs 京公网安备 11010802042870号 京ICP备2023020795号-1