Selection by Birds of Shrub and Tree Species in the Sahel

The Sahel is thinly covered by trees, but nevertheless forms an important habitat for millions of tree-dwelling birds. We describe tree availability and tree selection of 14 insectivorous Afro-Palearctic migrants and 18 Afro-tropical residents (10 insectivores, 3 frugivores and 5 nectarivores) inhabiting the Sahel from the Atlantic to the Red Sea. Of the 304 woody species identified across the region during systematic fieldwork in stratified plots, we noted height and canopy surface of 760,000 individual woody plants. Birds present in trees and shrubs were recorded separately per individual woody plant. 99.5% of the birds were concentrated in only 41 woody species. For 20 out of 32 bird species, Winter Thorn Faidherbia albida was the tree species most often used. Two other important tree species were Umbrella Thorn Acacia tortilis and Desert Date Balanites aegyptiaca. Representing only 11% of the total woody canopy cover, these three species attracted 89% of Western Bonelli's Warblers Phylloscopus bonelli and 77% of Subalpine Warblers Curruca iberiae + subalpina + cantillans. High selectivity for particular woody species was typical for migrants and residents, irrespective of their diet. Bird species feeding in shrubs used a larger variety of woody species than bird species feeding in tall trees. The highest bird densities (80–160 birds/ha canopy) were found in three shrubs with a limited distribution in the southern Sahara and northern Sahel: the berry-bearing Toothbrush Tree Salvadora persica, the small thorny shrub Sodad Capparis decidua and the small tree Maerua crassifolia. Other bird-rich woody species were without exception thorny (Balanites aegyptiaca, various species of acacia and ziziphus). In contrast, the five woody species most commonly distributed across the region (Cashew Anacardium occidentale, African Birch Anogeissus leiocarpus, Combretum glutinosum, Guiera senegalensis and Shea Tree Vitellaria paradoxa), representing 27% of the woody cover in the study sites, were rarely visited by foraging birds. In this sub-Saharan region, it is not total woody cover per se that matters to birds, but the presence of specific woody species. This finding has important implications: remote sensing studies showing global increase or decline of woody vegetation without identifying individual species have little value in explaining trends in arboreal bird populations. Local people have a large impact on the species composition of the woody vegetation in the Sahel, with positive and negative consequences for migrants wintering in this region. Faidherbia albida, the most important tree for birds in the sub-Saharan dry belt, is highly valued by local people and has the distinction of leafing in winter and being attractive to arthropods. On the other hand, migratory and African bird species have been negatively affected by the rapidly expanding cashew plantations since the early 1980s.