{"title":"\"You Have to Be Strong and Struggle\": Stigmas As Determinants of Inequality for Female Survivors of Sex Trafficking in Cambodia","authors":"T. Morrison, Vanntheary Lim","doi":"10.23860/dignity.2021.06.04.04","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Across the globe, human trafficking survivors have reported facing stigma and discrimination after reintegrating into communities. What makes stigma particularly dangerous is that it threatens what is “most at stake” in our lives, our close personal relationships and our personal life values. This paper explores longitudinal data from the Chab Dai Butterfly Longitudinal Research Project to document and describe forms of stigma and discrimination faced by survivors of sexual exploitation and trafficking living in Cambodian communities. Our research suggests stigmas associated with sex trafficking are a “fundamental determinant” of social inequality for many female survivors following reintegration. In this study, 56 women survivors discussed their encounters with stigma and discrimination interspersed with coping strategies and resilience attributes used to navigate life experiences. The majority (70%) spoke about contending with cultural stigma together with stigma from human trafficking experiences. Four main stigma causes dominated survivor narratives: gender, sex work, socioeconomic status, and marriageability. We use these causes, in combination with the voices of survivors, to develop a conceptual model of cohort experiences with stigma in Cambodia. Many survivors are conscious of negative stereotypes in their home communities before trafficking and discuss their struggles with self-stigmatizing thoughts and labels as they reintegrate back into their communities. Survivor discussions regarding stigmas associated with sex work show intense and persistent stigma layered over existing cultural stigmas and connected with a wide variety of societal discrimination and negative outcomes. This assessment identifies multiple disadvantaged outcomes for survivors in education, relationships, marital rights, and gender-based violence. We argue that these outcomes impact survivors' access/barriers to resources and life conditions related to job skills, employment opportunities, improving their socioeconomic status, mental and physical health, and other perceptions of family harmony, societal honor, and personal well-being.","PeriodicalId":347932,"journal":{"name":"Dignity: A Journal of Analysis of Exploitation and Violence","volume":"36 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2021-08-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"1","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Dignity: A Journal of Analysis of Exploitation and Violence","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.23860/dignity.2021.06.04.04","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 1
Abstract
Across the globe, human trafficking survivors have reported facing stigma and discrimination after reintegrating into communities. What makes stigma particularly dangerous is that it threatens what is “most at stake” in our lives, our close personal relationships and our personal life values. This paper explores longitudinal data from the Chab Dai Butterfly Longitudinal Research Project to document and describe forms of stigma and discrimination faced by survivors of sexual exploitation and trafficking living in Cambodian communities. Our research suggests stigmas associated with sex trafficking are a “fundamental determinant” of social inequality for many female survivors following reintegration. In this study, 56 women survivors discussed their encounters with stigma and discrimination interspersed with coping strategies and resilience attributes used to navigate life experiences. The majority (70%) spoke about contending with cultural stigma together with stigma from human trafficking experiences. Four main stigma causes dominated survivor narratives: gender, sex work, socioeconomic status, and marriageability. We use these causes, in combination with the voices of survivors, to develop a conceptual model of cohort experiences with stigma in Cambodia. Many survivors are conscious of negative stereotypes in their home communities before trafficking and discuss their struggles with self-stigmatizing thoughts and labels as they reintegrate back into their communities. Survivor discussions regarding stigmas associated with sex work show intense and persistent stigma layered over existing cultural stigmas and connected with a wide variety of societal discrimination and negative outcomes. This assessment identifies multiple disadvantaged outcomes for survivors in education, relationships, marital rights, and gender-based violence. We argue that these outcomes impact survivors' access/barriers to resources and life conditions related to job skills, employment opportunities, improving their socioeconomic status, mental and physical health, and other perceptions of family harmony, societal honor, and personal well-being.
在全球范围内,据报告,人口贩运幸存者在重新融入社区后面临耻辱和歧视。耻辱之所以特别危险,是因为它威胁到我们生活中“最危险”的东西,威胁到我们亲密的人际关系和个人生活价值观。本文探讨了Chab Dai Butterfly纵向研究项目的纵向数据,以记录和描述生活在柬埔寨社区的性剥削和贩运幸存者所面临的耻辱和歧视形式。我们的研究表明,对许多重新融入社会的女性幸存者来说,与性交易有关的耻辱是社会不平等的“根本决定因素”。在这项研究中,56名女性幸存者讨论了她们遭遇的耻辱和歧视,以及应对策略和适应能力,这些都是她们在生活经历中所使用的。大多数人(70%)谈到与文化耻辱以及人口贩运经历的耻辱作斗争。四种主要的耻辱导致了幸存者的叙述:性别、性工作、社会经济地位和婚姻能力。我们利用这些原因,结合幸存者的声音,开发了柬埔寨群体耻辱经历的概念模型。许多幸存者在被贩运之前就意识到其家乡社区的负面刻板印象,并讨论了他们在重新融入社区时与自我污名化思想和标签的斗争。幸存者对与性工作相关的污名的讨论表明,在现有的文化污名之上,存在着强烈而持久的污名,并与各种各样的社会歧视和负面结果有关。该评估确定了幸存者在教育、关系、婚姻权利和基于性别的暴力方面的多种不利结果。我们认为,这些结果影响了幸存者对资源和与工作技能、就业机会相关的生活条件的获取/障碍,改善了他们的社会经济地位、心理和身体健康,以及其他对家庭和谐、社会荣誉和个人福祉的看法。