Thread Similarity Matrix: Visualizing Branch Divergence in GPGPU Programs

Abstract

Graphics processing units (GPUs) have recently evolved into popular accelerators for general-purpose parallel programs -- so-called GPGPU computing. Although programming models such as CUDA and OpenCL significantly improve GPGPU programmability, optimizing GPGPU programs is still far from trivial. Branch divergence is one of the root causes reducing GPGPU performance. Existing approaches are able to calculate the branch divergence rate but are unable to reveal how the branches diverge in a GPGPU program. In this paper, we propose the Thread Similarity Matrix (TSM) to visualize how branches diverge and in turn help find optimization opportunities. TSM contains an element for each pair of threads, representing the difference in code being executed by the pair of threads. The darker the element, the more similar the threads are, the lighter, the more dissimilar. TSM therefore allows GPGPU programmers to easily understand an application's branch divergence behavior and pinpoint performance anomalies. We present a case study to demonstrate how TSM can help optimize GPGPU programs: we improve the performance of a highly-optimized GPGPU kernel by 35% by reorganizing its thread organization to reduce its branch divergence rate.