Григорий Тевелевич Фрумин, Евгения Сергеевна Негодина, Grigory Frumin, Evgenia Negodina
{"title":"Regional maximum permissible concentrations of metals in Lake Pskovskoye","authors":"Григорий Тевелевич Фрумин, Евгения Сергеевна Негодина, Grigory Frumin, Evgenia Negodina","doi":"10.17076/lim1760","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Natural water bodies located in different geographical regions of Russia vary widely in hydrochemical indicators of water quality. Despite this, unified federal water quality standards (MPCs) have been established for the entire territory of our country, without taking into account the formation process of quantitative and qualitative indicators of water quality in water bodies or respecting the natural uniqueness of the basins in which they are formed. The assessment of the surface water quality on the basis of federal maximum concentration limits completely ignores not only the specific and unique features of catchments but also their natural diversity. A collision arises when the concentrations of certain compounds do not interfere with the stability of the existing biocoenoses but fail to meet the maximum permissible concentrations for reservoirs used for fisheries (MPC), which apply to almost all water bodies in Russia. The purpose of this study is to substantiate the regional concentrations of metals in Lake Pskovskoye. The relevance of the study is due to the need to improve the MPC system for Lake Pskovskoye, which has a fishery value. The calculations were performed with hydrochemical monitoring data for the period 2000–2021. The results of the calculations of regional maximum permissible concentrations (MPCREG) for six metals (total iron, copper, lead, manganese, cadmium, zinc) are presented. Three different methods were used for the calculations: suggested by S. A. Patina, by D. G. Zamolodchikov, and by E. V. Venitsianov and co-authors. Calculations by Patina’s method involve two attributes - the average concentration of a chemical element for the period under review and the standard deviation. Calculations by the method of D.G. Zamolodchikov were based on the upper and lower quartiles of the distribution. The method of E.V. Venitsianov and co-authors employs three attributes - the sample size, the upper quartile of the distribution, and the standard deviation for the quantile of about 0.75. Proceeding from the principle of sanitary maximalism, we argue that the optimal method for calculating metal MPCREGs is the method suggested by E. V. Venitsianov and co-authors. The regional maximum permisslbe concentrations of metals in Lake Pskovskoye proved to tightly correlate with their clarke numbers in the earth’s crust.","PeriodicalId":33861,"journal":{"name":"Transactions of the Karelian Research Centre of the Russian Academy of Sciences","volume":"5 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2023-10-25","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Transactions of the Karelian Research Centre of the Russian Academy of Sciences","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.17076/lim1760","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Natural water bodies located in different geographical regions of Russia vary widely in hydrochemical indicators of water quality. Despite this, unified federal water quality standards (MPCs) have been established for the entire territory of our country, without taking into account the formation process of quantitative and qualitative indicators of water quality in water bodies or respecting the natural uniqueness of the basins in which they are formed. The assessment of the surface water quality on the basis of federal maximum concentration limits completely ignores not only the specific and unique features of catchments but also their natural diversity. A collision arises when the concentrations of certain compounds do not interfere with the stability of the existing biocoenoses but fail to meet the maximum permissible concentrations for reservoirs used for fisheries (MPC), which apply to almost all water bodies in Russia. The purpose of this study is to substantiate the regional concentrations of metals in Lake Pskovskoye. The relevance of the study is due to the need to improve the MPC system for Lake Pskovskoye, which has a fishery value. The calculations were performed with hydrochemical monitoring data for the period 2000–2021. The results of the calculations of regional maximum permissible concentrations (MPCREG) for six metals (total iron, copper, lead, manganese, cadmium, zinc) are presented. Three different methods were used for the calculations: suggested by S. A. Patina, by D. G. Zamolodchikov, and by E. V. Venitsianov and co-authors. Calculations by Patina’s method involve two attributes - the average concentration of a chemical element for the period under review and the standard deviation. Calculations by the method of D.G. Zamolodchikov were based on the upper and lower quartiles of the distribution. The method of E.V. Venitsianov and co-authors employs three attributes - the sample size, the upper quartile of the distribution, and the standard deviation for the quantile of about 0.75. Proceeding from the principle of sanitary maximalism, we argue that the optimal method for calculating metal MPCREGs is the method suggested by E. V. Venitsianov and co-authors. The regional maximum permisslbe concentrations of metals in Lake Pskovskoye proved to tightly correlate with their clarke numbers in the earth’s crust.
俄罗斯不同地理区域的天然水体水质水化学指标差异很大。尽管如此,为我国全境制定了统一的联邦水质标准(MPCs),但没有考虑水体中水质定量和定性指标的形成过程,也没有尊重形成这些指标的流域的自然独特性。根据联邦最高浓度限值对地表水质量进行评价,不仅完全忽视了集水区的特殊性和独特性,而且也忽视了集水区的自然多样性。当某些化合物的浓度不干扰现有生物群落的稳定性,但未能达到渔业水库的最大允许浓度(MPC)时,就会发生碰撞,这适用于俄罗斯几乎所有的水体。本研究的目的是证实普斯科夫斯科耶湖金属的区域浓度。这项研究的相关性是由于需要改善具有渔业价值的普斯科夫斯科耶湖的MPC系统。计算是根据2000-2021年期间的水化学监测数据进行的。给出了六种金属(总铁、铜、铅、锰、镉、锌)区域最大允许浓度(MPCREG)的计算结果。三种不同的计算方法分别由S. A. Patina、D. G. Zamolodchikov和E. V. Venitsianov及其合著者提出。帕蒂纳的计算方法涉及两个属性——一种化学元素在审查期间的平均浓度和标准偏差。通过D.G. Zamolodchikov方法的计算是基于分布的上、下四分位数。E.V. Venitsianov及其合作者的方法采用了三个属性——样本量、分布的上四分位数以及大约0.75的分位数的标准偏差。从卫生极值原则出发,我们认为计算金属mpcreg的最佳方法是e.v. Venitsianov及其合作者提出的方法。普斯科夫斯科耶湖的区域最大允许金属浓度被证明与地壳中的克拉克数量密切相关。