Joseph M. Birkmann, Bruce B. Huckell, M. Steven Shackley, C. Vance Haynes
{"title":"The Paleoindian and Archaic Occupation of Grants, New Mexico: A Review and Reanalysis of the Grants San Jose Sites and Projectile Point Collections","authors":"Joseph M. Birkmann, Bruce B. Huckell, M. Steven Shackley, C. Vance Haynes","doi":"10.1080/00231940.2023.2248806","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"AbstractIn the late 1930s Joseph Toulouse Jr., Kirk Bryan, and Bryan McCann published two articles describing the archaeology and geology of seventeen preceramic sites near Grants, New Mexico. George Agogino, Jim Hester, and William Roosa periodically revisited a subset of these sites during the 50s and 60s, publishing three brief articles and collecting additional artifacts. Despite the importance of these sites to the history of preceramic research in Northern New Mexico, no complete inventory or analysis of the projectile point collections has been undertaken to date. In this article, we provide: (1) a brief history of the Grants San Jose collections, (2) an inventory of diagnostic projectile points, (3) an analysis of raw materials represented and geochemical analysis of a sample of volcanic dart points, and (4) a brief discussion of the collections’ implications for the pre-ceramic archaeology of the Grants area.A fines de la década de 1930, Joseph Toulouse Jr., Kirk Bryan y Bryan McCann publicaron dos artículos que describen la arqueología y la geología de diecisiete sitios precerámicos cerca de Grants, Nuevo México. George Agogino, Jim Hester y William Roosa revisaron periódicamente un subconjunto de estos sitios durante los años 50 y 60, publicaron tres artículos breves y recolectaron artefactos adicionales. A pesar de la importancia de estos sitios en la historia de las investigaciones precerámicas en el norte de Nuevo México, hasta la fecha no se ha realizado ningún inventario o análisis completo de las colecciones de puntas de proyectil. En este artículo mostramos: (1) una breve historia de las colecciones de Grants San Jose, (2) el inventario de puntas de proyectil diagnósticas, (3) los resultados de los análisis de las materias primas representadas y del análisis geoquímico de una muestra de puntas de dardo volcánicas, y (4) una breve discusión de las implicaciones de las colecciones para la arqueología precerámica del área de Grants.KEYWORDS: ArchaicSouthwestprojectile pointslithic analysisGrantsSan JosetypologyPaleoindian AcknowledgmentsThe authors would like to thank Maxwell Museum staff Karen Price (Collections Manager), Chip Wills (Acting Curator), and Diane Tyink for their assistance. Likewise, we would like to recognize the current and former members of the Museum of Indian Arts and Culture Staff, including Maxine McBrinn, Julia Clifton, Diana Sherman, and C. L. Kieffer for their assistance. This manuscript was also improved by conversations and correspondence with Karl Laumbach (HSR), Pat Hogan (OCA), Robin Cordero (OCA), and Christopher Merriman (UNM). We would also like to thank Kirk Bryan, Jr. for granting us access to the correspondence and papers of his father, Kirk Bryan, and the Harvard Archives staff, including Megan Sniffin-Marinoff. New Mexico State University Archivist Dennis Daily and Molly Molloy provided assistance in scanning and providing copies of reports generated by Karl Laumbauch and companies work at the Grants Women's Prison. The Spanish language abstract was generously translated by M. Lourdes Iniesta. Finally, we would like to thank Charles Harding for permission to access his property along East Grants Ridge in 2020.Disclosure StatementNo potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).Notes1 All radiocarbon dates calibrated using OxCal 4.4 and the IntCal20 calibration curve.","PeriodicalId":44778,"journal":{"name":"Kiva-Journal of Southwestern Anthropology and History","volume":"64 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.5000,"publicationDate":"2023-09-16","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Kiva-Journal of Southwestern Anthropology and History","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1080/00231940.2023.2248806","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"0","JCRName":"ARCHAEOLOGY","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
AbstractIn the late 1930s Joseph Toulouse Jr., Kirk Bryan, and Bryan McCann published two articles describing the archaeology and geology of seventeen preceramic sites near Grants, New Mexico. George Agogino, Jim Hester, and William Roosa periodically revisited a subset of these sites during the 50s and 60s, publishing three brief articles and collecting additional artifacts. Despite the importance of these sites to the history of preceramic research in Northern New Mexico, no complete inventory or analysis of the projectile point collections has been undertaken to date. In this article, we provide: (1) a brief history of the Grants San Jose collections, (2) an inventory of diagnostic projectile points, (3) an analysis of raw materials represented and geochemical analysis of a sample of volcanic dart points, and (4) a brief discussion of the collections’ implications for the pre-ceramic archaeology of the Grants area.A fines de la década de 1930, Joseph Toulouse Jr., Kirk Bryan y Bryan McCann publicaron dos artículos que describen la arqueología y la geología de diecisiete sitios precerámicos cerca de Grants, Nuevo México. George Agogino, Jim Hester y William Roosa revisaron periódicamente un subconjunto de estos sitios durante los años 50 y 60, publicaron tres artículos breves y recolectaron artefactos adicionales. A pesar de la importancia de estos sitios en la historia de las investigaciones precerámicas en el norte de Nuevo México, hasta la fecha no se ha realizado ningún inventario o análisis completo de las colecciones de puntas de proyectil. En este artículo mostramos: (1) una breve historia de las colecciones de Grants San Jose, (2) el inventario de puntas de proyectil diagnósticas, (3) los resultados de los análisis de las materias primas representadas y del análisis geoquímico de una muestra de puntas de dardo volcánicas, y (4) una breve discusión de las implicaciones de las colecciones para la arqueología precerámica del área de Grants.KEYWORDS: ArchaicSouthwestprojectile pointslithic analysisGrantsSan JosetypologyPaleoindian AcknowledgmentsThe authors would like to thank Maxwell Museum staff Karen Price (Collections Manager), Chip Wills (Acting Curator), and Diane Tyink for their assistance. Likewise, we would like to recognize the current and former members of the Museum of Indian Arts and Culture Staff, including Maxine McBrinn, Julia Clifton, Diana Sherman, and C. L. Kieffer for their assistance. This manuscript was also improved by conversations and correspondence with Karl Laumbach (HSR), Pat Hogan (OCA), Robin Cordero (OCA), and Christopher Merriman (UNM). We would also like to thank Kirk Bryan, Jr. for granting us access to the correspondence and papers of his father, Kirk Bryan, and the Harvard Archives staff, including Megan Sniffin-Marinoff. New Mexico State University Archivist Dennis Daily and Molly Molloy provided assistance in scanning and providing copies of reports generated by Karl Laumbauch and companies work at the Grants Women's Prison. The Spanish language abstract was generously translated by M. Lourdes Iniesta. Finally, we would like to thank Charles Harding for permission to access his property along East Grants Ridge in 2020.Disclosure StatementNo potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).Notes1 All radiocarbon dates calibrated using OxCal 4.4 and the IntCal20 calibration curve.
20世纪30年代末,小约瑟夫·图卢兹(Joseph Toulouse Jr.)、柯克·布莱恩(Kirk Bryan)和布莱恩·麦卡恩(Bryan McCann)发表了两篇文章,描述了新墨西哥州格兰特附近17个史前陶器遗址的考古学和地质学。George Agogino, Jim Hester和William Roosa在50年代和60年代定期重新访问这些遗址的一个子集,发表了三篇简短的文章并收集了额外的文物。尽管这些地点对新墨西哥州北部的史前陶瓷研究历史具有重要意义,但迄今为止还没有对抛射点收集进行完整的清单或分析。在本文中,我们提供:(1)格兰茨圣何塞藏品的简史,(2)诊断弹丸点的清单,(3)所代表的原材料分析和火山弹丸点样本的地球化学分析,以及(4)简要讨论这些藏品对格兰茨地区前陶瓷考古学的影响。1930年,Joseph Toulouse Jr., Kirk Bryan和Bryan McCann公开发表了artículos que descridla arqueología y . geología de diecisiete sisios precerámicos cerca de Grants, Nuevo m录影带。George Agogino, Jim Hester和William Roosa修订periódicamente次连接到de estos站点durante los años 50 y 60,公开树artículos通过回忆文物词典的简要介绍。关于调查历史中调查情况的重要性的报告(precerámicas)和关于新墨西哥的调查历史的报告(1)的报告(1)表明,已经实现了ningún和análisis关于保护问题的收集工作的完整目录。En este artículo mostramos:(1)圣何塞大学的历史研究,(2)保护之城的发明研究diagnósticas,(3)研究结果研究análisis主要材料研究代表研究análisis geoquímico大学的建筑研究volcánicas,(4)研究discusión关于大学的隐含意义研究arqueología precerámica del área格兰兹。作者要感谢麦克斯韦博物馆的工作人员Karen Price(藏品经理)、Chip Wills(代理馆长)和Diane Tyink的协助。同样,我们要感谢印第安艺术与文化博物馆的现任和前任工作人员,包括玛克辛·麦克布林、朱莉娅·克利夫顿、戴安娜·谢尔曼和c·l·基弗,感谢他们的帮助。本文还通过与Karl Laumbach (HSR)、Pat Hogan (OCA)、Robin Cordero (OCA)和Christopher Merriman (UNM)的对话和通信进行了改进。我们还要感谢小柯克·布莱恩(Kirk Bryan, Jr.)允许我们查阅他父亲柯克·布莱恩(Kirk Bryan, Jr.)和哈佛档案馆工作人员(包括梅根·斯尼芬-马里诺夫)的信件和文件。新墨西哥州立大学档案管理员丹尼斯·戴利和莫莉·莫洛伊协助扫描并提供了由卡尔·劳姆巴赫和在格兰茨女子监狱工作的公司生成的报告的副本。西班牙语摘要由卢尔德·伊涅斯塔先生慷慨地翻译。最后,我们要感谢查尔斯·哈丁允许我们在2020年进入他在东格兰特岭的房产。披露声明作者未报告潜在的利益冲突。注1所有放射性碳年代均使用oxcal4.4和IntCal20校准曲线校准。