Valentina V. Gritsenko, Nadezhda V. Murashcenkova, Maria N. Efremenkova
{"title":"A retrospective study of the ethnic identity development in the childhood: Analysis of ethnic autobiographies of high school students","authors":"Valentina V. Gritsenko, Nadezhda V. Murashcenkova, Maria N. Efremenkova","doi":"10.18500/2304-9790-2023-12-3-246-255","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"The contradiction between the necessity to identify the resource potential of ethnic identity in modern conditions, on the one hand, and the contradictory data on its development in persons whose socialization takes place in an ethnically homogeneous environment, on the other hand, makes the study issue relevant. The research purpose: a retrospective study of the ethnic identity development in high school students living in a mono-ethnic Russian region – the Smolensk region. Research questions: At what age do children living in a mono-ethnic environment acquire the first information about their own and other ethnic groups? How do children feel about their ethnic group in the process of identifying with it? What is the role of the family in shaping the ethnic identity of children? The study participants are 185 secondary school students from Smolensk who identify themselves as Russians, aged from 15 to 18; the average age is 16.3 years old; 59.5% of them are females. The research methods (tools) used: the technique “Ethnic autobiography” (by P. V. Rumyantseva), aimed at studying the development of ethnic identity in the childhood. The processing of the research results was carried out with the help of frequency and content analysis methods. The research results: most of the students acquired their first knowledge of Russian and other ethnic groups at preschool and primary school age and experienced positive feelings about their ethnicity. A third of the high school students showed an indifferent attitude to their ethnicity. The contribution of the family to the ethnic identity development weakens in a situation where parents belong to different nationalities or when the children do not know their parents’ nationality. The main conclusions. Development of the ethnic identity of the majority of high school students, who live in a mono-ethnic Russian environment, takes place in the process of family upbringing, it is smooth, without any shocks and changes, it is characterized by a positive attitude towards their belonging to the Russian ethnic group. The indifferent attitude of some high school students to their ethnicity may, on the one hand, indicate its irrelevance and insignificance for children living in a mono–ethnic environment, and on the other hand, it can be considered as an indicator of a “hidden” identity that can be actualized under certain conditions. The research findings should be taken into account in order to increase the effectiveness of intercultural interaction and to develop national civil Russian consolidation.","PeriodicalId":476403,"journal":{"name":"Izvestiâ Saratovskogo universiteta. Novaâ seriâ","volume":"191 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2023-09-22","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Izvestiâ Saratovskogo universiteta. Novaâ seriâ","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.18500/2304-9790-2023-12-3-246-255","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
The contradiction between the necessity to identify the resource potential of ethnic identity in modern conditions, on the one hand, and the contradictory data on its development in persons whose socialization takes place in an ethnically homogeneous environment, on the other hand, makes the study issue relevant. The research purpose: a retrospective study of the ethnic identity development in high school students living in a mono-ethnic Russian region – the Smolensk region. Research questions: At what age do children living in a mono-ethnic environment acquire the first information about their own and other ethnic groups? How do children feel about their ethnic group in the process of identifying with it? What is the role of the family in shaping the ethnic identity of children? The study participants are 185 secondary school students from Smolensk who identify themselves as Russians, aged from 15 to 18; the average age is 16.3 years old; 59.5% of them are females. The research methods (tools) used: the technique “Ethnic autobiography” (by P. V. Rumyantseva), aimed at studying the development of ethnic identity in the childhood. The processing of the research results was carried out with the help of frequency and content analysis methods. The research results: most of the students acquired their first knowledge of Russian and other ethnic groups at preschool and primary school age and experienced positive feelings about their ethnicity. A third of the high school students showed an indifferent attitude to their ethnicity. The contribution of the family to the ethnic identity development weakens in a situation where parents belong to different nationalities or when the children do not know their parents’ nationality. The main conclusions. Development of the ethnic identity of the majority of high school students, who live in a mono-ethnic Russian environment, takes place in the process of family upbringing, it is smooth, without any shocks and changes, it is characterized by a positive attitude towards their belonging to the Russian ethnic group. The indifferent attitude of some high school students to their ethnicity may, on the one hand, indicate its irrelevance and insignificance for children living in a mono–ethnic environment, and on the other hand, it can be considered as an indicator of a “hidden” identity that can be actualized under certain conditions. The research findings should be taken into account in order to increase the effectiveness of intercultural interaction and to develop national civil Russian consolidation.
一方面,在现代条件下识别民族身份资源潜力的必要性,另一方面,在种族同质环境中进行社会化的人身上,其发展的矛盾数据,使研究问题具有现实意义。研究目的:对俄罗斯单一民族地区——斯摩棱斯克地区高中生的族群认同发展进行回顾性研究。研究问题:生活在单一民族环境中的儿童在几岁时第一次获得关于本民族和其他民族的信息?在认同的过程中,孩子们对自己的族群有什么感觉?家庭在塑造儿童的种族认同方面扮演什么角色?这项研究的参与者是来自斯摩棱斯克的185名中学生,他们认为自己是俄罗斯人,年龄在15岁到18岁之间;平均年龄为16.3岁;其中59.5%为女性。使用的研究方法(工具):“民族自传”技术(P. V. Rumyantseva),旨在研究儿童时期民族认同的发展。利用频率分析法和含量分析法对研究结果进行处理。研究结果表明:大多数学生在学龄前和小学阶段获得了对俄罗斯和其他民族的第一次认识,并对自己的民族产生了积极的感受。三分之一的高中生对自己的种族表现出漠不关心的态度。在父母属于不同民族或儿童不知道父母国籍的情况下,家庭对民族认同发展的贡献减弱。主要结论。大多数高中学生的民族认同的发展,是生活在单一民族的俄罗斯环境中,发生在家庭的成长过程中,它是顺利的,没有任何的冲击和变化,它的特点是对自己属于俄罗斯民族的积极态度。一些高中生对自己种族的冷漠态度,一方面可能表明它对于生活在单一民族环境中的孩子来说是不相关和不重要的,另一方面,它可以被认为是在一定条件下可以实现的“隐藏”身份的一个指标。应该考虑到研究结果,以提高文化间互动的有效性,并发展民族民间俄罗斯的巩固。