Asuman Buyukcan-Tetik, Mustafa Anil Topal, Belgin Deryalar, Turan Deniz Ergun, Eda Nur Aydin, Bulent Aykutoglu
{"title":"Bereaved Parents’ Change in Mental Health during a Dyadic Diary","authors":"Asuman Buyukcan-Tetik, Mustafa Anil Topal, Belgin Deryalar, Turan Deniz Ergun, Eda Nur Aydin, Bulent Aykutoglu","doi":"10.1080/15325024.2023.2267420","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"AbstractRecent years have seen a shift in the number of bereavement studies examining daily grief processes, but our knowledge is still limited due to the lack of dyadic research. In this paper, we explored the change in mental health in the course of a seven-day dyadic diary with bereaved couples who lost their child during pregnancy, labor, or afterward. We conducted dyadic latent growth curve analyses. In the bereaved parents who experienced a pregnancy loss, we found reduced grief (for both partners) and anxiety symptoms (only for women) and no changes in depression symptoms or personal strength levels across the diary days. In the bereaved parents who lost their child during labor or afterward, both partners’ grief and depression symptoms and women’s anxiety symptoms stayed stable, men’s anxiety symptoms decreased, but women experienced a decline in their personal strength. Overall, negative aspects of mental health showed no sign of a dyadic diary’s harm to the bereaved parents and even pointed to increased mental health in some respects during the study. However, a feeling of reduced capacity to deal with difficulties during the diary was also observed in women. Our findings indicated that both negative and positive aspects of mental health should be considered to evaluate the impact of diary studies on the participants.Keywords: Bereaved parentschild lossmental healthdyadic diaryintensive longitudinal methods AcknowledgmentsThe authors thank the research assistants and volunteers for their help in all project steps, Samet Baş for sharing the Turkish version of the Traumatic Grief Inventory-Self Report before it was published, and Maarten C. Eisma for his suggestions during the project. We are grateful to our participants for their contribution to our project.Disclosure statementThe authors report no conflicts of interest to declare.Data availability statementGiven the sensitivity of the topic and dyadic data, we did not share our dataset publicly. Data can be requested from the first author.Ethics statementThis research was approved by the Research Ethics Council of the first author’s Institution (FASS-2020-45). The participants filled in the surveys after they provided informed consent.Additional informationFundingThis research was funded by a grant from the Scientific and Technological Research Council of Turkey (Türkiye Bilimsel ve Teknolojik Araştırma Kurumu) to the first author (Grant number: 119K404).Notes on contributorsAsuman Buyukcan-TetikAsuman Buyukcan-Tetik was an Assistant Professor in the Psychology Program at Sabanci University, Turkey, during this research. She investigates major life events’ consequences for mental health and relational well-being.Mustafa Anil TopalMustafa Anil Topal is a master’s student in the Psychology Program at Sabanci University, Turkey. His research focuses on romantic relationships, socioeconomic status, and grief.Belgin DeryalarBelgin Deryalar was a psychology master’s student at Sabanci University, Turkey, during this research. Her research interests include visual and verbal memory and grief.Turan Deniz ErgunTuran Deniz Ergun was a psychology master’s student at Sabanci University. His research interests include close relationships, affectionate touch, and grief.Eda Nur AydinEda Nur Aydin was an undergraduate student at Hacettepe University, Turkey, during this research. Her research interests are trauma, loss, and grief.Bulent AykutogluBulent Aykutoglu is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Psychology at Nuh Naci Yazgan University, Turkey. His research focuses on basic psychological needs and mental and physical health.","PeriodicalId":47527,"journal":{"name":"Journal of Loss & Trauma","volume":"1 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":2.5000,"publicationDate":"2023-10-27","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Journal of Loss & Trauma","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1080/15325024.2023.2267420","RegionNum":4,"RegionCategory":"心理学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q2","JCRName":"PSYCHOLOGY, SOCIAL","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
AbstractRecent years have seen a shift in the number of bereavement studies examining daily grief processes, but our knowledge is still limited due to the lack of dyadic research. In this paper, we explored the change in mental health in the course of a seven-day dyadic diary with bereaved couples who lost their child during pregnancy, labor, or afterward. We conducted dyadic latent growth curve analyses. In the bereaved parents who experienced a pregnancy loss, we found reduced grief (for both partners) and anxiety symptoms (only for women) and no changes in depression symptoms or personal strength levels across the diary days. In the bereaved parents who lost their child during labor or afterward, both partners’ grief and depression symptoms and women’s anxiety symptoms stayed stable, men’s anxiety symptoms decreased, but women experienced a decline in their personal strength. Overall, negative aspects of mental health showed no sign of a dyadic diary’s harm to the bereaved parents and even pointed to increased mental health in some respects during the study. However, a feeling of reduced capacity to deal with difficulties during the diary was also observed in women. Our findings indicated that both negative and positive aspects of mental health should be considered to evaluate the impact of diary studies on the participants.Keywords: Bereaved parentschild lossmental healthdyadic diaryintensive longitudinal methods AcknowledgmentsThe authors thank the research assistants and volunteers for their help in all project steps, Samet Baş for sharing the Turkish version of the Traumatic Grief Inventory-Self Report before it was published, and Maarten C. Eisma for his suggestions during the project. We are grateful to our participants for their contribution to our project.Disclosure statementThe authors report no conflicts of interest to declare.Data availability statementGiven the sensitivity of the topic and dyadic data, we did not share our dataset publicly. Data can be requested from the first author.Ethics statementThis research was approved by the Research Ethics Council of the first author’s Institution (FASS-2020-45). The participants filled in the surveys after they provided informed consent.Additional informationFundingThis research was funded by a grant from the Scientific and Technological Research Council of Turkey (Türkiye Bilimsel ve Teknolojik Araştırma Kurumu) to the first author (Grant number: 119K404).Notes on contributorsAsuman Buyukcan-TetikAsuman Buyukcan-Tetik was an Assistant Professor in the Psychology Program at Sabanci University, Turkey, during this research. She investigates major life events’ consequences for mental health and relational well-being.Mustafa Anil TopalMustafa Anil Topal is a master’s student in the Psychology Program at Sabanci University, Turkey. His research focuses on romantic relationships, socioeconomic status, and grief.Belgin DeryalarBelgin Deryalar was a psychology master’s student at Sabanci University, Turkey, during this research. Her research interests include visual and verbal memory and grief.Turan Deniz ErgunTuran Deniz Ergun was a psychology master’s student at Sabanci University. His research interests include close relationships, affectionate touch, and grief.Eda Nur AydinEda Nur Aydin was an undergraduate student at Hacettepe University, Turkey, during this research. Her research interests are trauma, loss, and grief.Bulent AykutogluBulent Aykutoglu is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Psychology at Nuh Naci Yazgan University, Turkey. His research focuses on basic psychological needs and mental and physical health.
摘要近年来,研究日常悲伤过程的丧亲研究数量有所变化,但由于缺乏二元研究,我们的知识仍然有限。在这篇论文中,我们探讨了在怀孕、分娩或分娩后失去孩子的夫妇在7天的双日记过程中心理健康的变化。我们进行了二元潜在生长曲线分析。在失去孩子的父母中,我们发现悲伤(双方都有)和焦虑症状(仅对女性)减少了,在日记的日子里,抑郁症状或个人力量水平没有变化。在分娩过程中或分娩后失去孩子的父母中,夫妻双方的悲伤和抑郁症状以及女性的焦虑症状都保持稳定,男性的焦虑症状有所减轻,但女性的个人力量有所下降。总的来说,心理健康的消极方面没有显示出双重日记对失去亲人的父母造成伤害的迹象,甚至在研究期间指出了心理健康在某些方面的增加。然而,在写日记的过程中,女性也会感到处理困难的能力下降。我们的研究结果表明,在评估日记研究对参与者的影响时,应考虑心理健康的消极和积极方面。作者感谢研究助理和志愿者在项目的所有步骤中提供的帮助,感谢Samet baku在《创伤性悲伤量表-自我报告》出版前分享了土耳其语版,感谢Maarten C. Eisma在项目过程中提出的建议。我们非常感谢我们的参与者对我们项目的贡献。声明作者无利益冲突需要申报。数据可用性声明考虑到主题和二元数据的敏感性,我们没有公开共享我们的数据集。可以向第一作者索取数据。伦理声明本研究经第一作者所在机构研究伦理委员会(FASS-2020-45)批准。参与者在提供知情同意后填写调查问卷。本研究由土耳其科学技术研究委员会(t rkiye Bilimsel ve Teknolojik Araştırma Kurumu)资助第一作者(资助号:119K404)。在这项研究中,suman Buyukcan-Tetik是土耳其萨班奇大学心理学项目的助理教授。她研究生活中的重大事件对心理健康和人际关系的影响。Mustafa Anil Topal是土耳其萨班奇大学心理学专业的硕士生。他的研究重点是恋爱关系、社会经济地位和悲伤。在这项研究中,Belgin Deryalar是土耳其萨班奇大学的一名心理学硕士研究生。她的研究兴趣包括视觉和言语记忆以及悲伤。Turan Deniz Ergun是萨班齐大学心理学硕士研究生。他的研究兴趣包括亲密关系、深情触摸和悲伤。Eda Nur Aydin在进行这项研究时是土耳其Hacettepe大学的一名本科生。她的研究兴趣是创伤、失去和悲伤。Bulent Aykutoglu是土耳其Nuh Naci Yazgan大学心理学系助理教授。他的研究重点是基本心理需求和身心健康。
期刊介绍:
In one forum, Journal of Loss and Trauma brings together scholarship on personal losses relating to family, health, and aging issues. The journal addresses issues dealing with psychological and physical health and interpersonal losses relative to extended family, community life, and society as a whole. In order to broaden the reader"s perspective on loss and bereavement, the journal defines loss as a major reduction in a person"s resources, whether personal, material, or symbolic, to which the person was emotionally attached. Types of loss covered include: death and dying; dissolution and divorce; loss of employment; life-threatening diseases and long-term disability; loss of possessions; homelessness.