Finite element study of the fatigue behaviour of nickel-titanium endodontic files utilised with pecking motion technique

Abstract

The purpose of the study is to evaluate the influence of the pecking motion (reciprocal axial motion) surgical technique on the durability behaviour of the Nickel-Titanium endodontic files using Finite Element Analysis (FEA). A commonly used endodontic file, ProTaper Universal F2, is selected for the study. Root canal treatment procedure is simulated on a test-bench (simulated root canal) proposed by G. Gambarini for cyclic fatigue loading of endodontic files with and without the pecking motion via FEA. The hysteresis energy density is used as evaluation criteria for low cycle fatigue life estimation of Shape Memory Alloy files. In an additional study, the root canal treatment procedure is also simulated for an FEA model of a molar tooth with significant root canal curvature to understand the influence of the realistic curvature of a root canal on the fatigue behaviour of endodontic files. For the simulated root canal, analysis accurately predicts the endodontic file's failure location, and fatigue life estimation based on the hysteresis energy density is shown to increase significantly with the introduction of the pecking motion, an observation confirmed by reported experimental results. Molar tooth simulations reveal greater file fatigue resistance than in simulated root canals, confirming the pecking motion's efficacy in enhancing file durability, even in real root canal conditions. Simulations indicate that the pecking motion technique increases the fatigue life of endodontic files for simulated as well as real root canals and the hysteresis energy is confirmed as an acceptable parameter to quantify fatigue life of Nickel-Titanium endodontic files.