Reliability of the Risser+ grade for assessment of bone maturity in pediatric scoliosis cases: Investigation using standing and supine whole-spine radiograph

Abstract

Background

Although several radiography-based systems for assessing skeletal maturity are available to clinicians, the classical Risser grading system remains a clinical gold standard. For scoliosis follow-up, a standing whole-spine radiograph is usually used. However, in our clinical practice, we have occasionally encountered cases in which ossification of the iliac crest is seen differently in the standing and supine whole-spine radiography. Here, we aimed to clarify the reliability of the Risser+ grading system for supine versus standing position radiographs.

Methods

This study recruited patients with all types of scoliosis who had been radiographed in both the standing and supine positions. We retrospectively evaluated the Risser+ grade of standing and supine whole-spine radiographs taken consecutively. Kappa statistics were computed to investigate the agreement between standing and supine Risser+ grades for this study.

Results

We evaluated 111 patients (age: 12.6 ± 2.0; male-to-female = 23:88). The Kappa value for the standing and supine Risser+ grade systems was 0.74. The degree of agreement between the two positions for each Risser+ grade revealed high agreement for grades 0 and 5 in all cases, whereas grades 2 and 3 had low agreement.

Conclusions

Overall, there was substantial agreement between the Risser+ grades assigned to standing and supine position radiographs. However, disagreement was observed between standing and supine position radiographs assigned Risser+ grades of 2 or 3. Therefore, we have found a wide range in the visibility of iliac apophysis ossification of the iliac depending on the posture, and there are limitations in assessing bone maturity using the Risser+ grade alone. Clinicians should use other evaluation systems, in addition to the Risser+ system, to achieve a more accurate bone maturity assessment, especially for cases with standing position radiographs assigned Risser grades of 2 or 3.