Academic versus Community Retinal Surgery for Primary Retinal Detachment

Abstract

Purpose

To compare operative time and case characteristics of primary rhegmatogenous retinal detachment (RRD) repairs between academic and community vitreoretinal surgeons.

Design

A retrospective, observational clinical study.

Subjects

Patients who underwent primary RRD repair surgeries at Massachusetts Eye and Ear between 2019 and 2021.

Methods

A random sample of 20 vitreoretinal surgeons distributed evenly among the academic or community setting was selected. Fifteen consecutive cases of primary RRD repair surgeries were included from each surgeon. A cost analysis was performed for the teaching modifier for the physician fee and for hospital costs.

Main Outcome Measures

Length of surgery.

Results

Of 300 primary RRD repairs, fellows were present in 75%, which comprised all academic surgeon cases and 50% of community surgeon cases, P < 0.001. Mean operation length was shorter for community surgeon cases without fellows (55.0 ± 24.1) than either academic (73.0 ± 30.8) or community surgeon cases with fellows (75.7 ± 32.5) (P < 0.001). There was a higher percentage of macula-off RRDs in academic versus community surgeon cases (52.7% vs. 38.0%, P = 0.002) and higher rates of combined scleral buckle (SB)/pars plana vitrectomy (PPV) repairs (14% vs. 3%, P < 0.001). When excluding combined SB/PPV cases, there was no difference in operative time between academic and community surgeon cases. Among RRDs repaired by PPV only, there was a 31.4% (16.6 minutes) greater procedure duration in cases with fellows compared with cases without fellows (P < 0.001). Covariates associated with greater surgery time: addition of an SB (β = 32.6), membrane peel (β = 18.5), presence of a fellow (β = 14.5), proliferative vitreoretinopathy (β = 12.8), and greater number of retinal breaks (β = 2.4). The teaching modifier adds 16% extra reimbursement ($184.16) to the physician fee, which is 50.9% of what is necessary to cover the percentage increase in surgeon time (31.4%). Using a time-driven activity-based costing for hospital costs, the extra 16.6 minutes leads to an additional $1038.00, which is 5.6 times more than the reimbursement for the modifier.

Conclusions

Retinal detachment repair cases performed by academic surgeons are more likely to be macula-off and include the addition of an SB, which drive longer operative times. Medicare’s reimbursement of the assistant modifier in a teaching facility significantly undercompensates the time-driven activity-based costing of trainee participation.

Financial Disclosure(s)

Proprietary or commercial disclosure may be found in the Footnotes and Disclosures at the end of this article.