K. Sum, A. Cheshire, D. Ridge, D. Sengupta, S. Deb
{"title":"Doctors’ and nurses’ eating practices during shift work: Findings from a qualitative study","authors":"K. Sum, A. Cheshire, D. Ridge, D. Sengupta, S. Deb","doi":"10.1017/s0029665124004282","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Doctors’ and nurses’ (DNs) wellbeing in the National Health Service is important for safe healthcare for those in need. However, their demanding duties, including irregular shift work, can significantly impact their health. Unfortunately, irregular working patterns are associated with higher sickness rates and stress among healthcare professionals due to the inherent challenges of the work<jats:sup>(1,2)</jats:sup>. For example, shift work disrupts sleep and impairs cognitive function and performance, leading to poorer physiological and cardiovascular health<jats:sup>(3)</jats:sup>, workforce shortages and difficulties adapting to a consistently demanding workload, which can impact patient care delivery<jats:sup>(4)</jats:sup>. Despite the importance of workplace health and nutrition for DNs, our understanding of their dietary practices during shift work remains limited. Therefore, gaining insights into DNs’ eating habits during shifts is imperative to supporting their health. Our research aimed to understand DNs’ eating practices during their work, including the types of food consumed throughout the day.Online semi-structured interviews (n=16) were conducted with a convenience sample of current practising medical doctors (n=11) and nurses (n=5) in England. This provided an opportunity to compare and contrast the research data between DNs on workplace nutrition. All participants did shift work, encompassing varied working patterns, including day and night shifts, short and long days and weekends. Following Braun and Clarke’s<jats:sup>(5)</jats:sup> approach, an inductive thematic analysis presented the findings.Results elucidate six areas of DNs’ eating practices and dietary intake: before and during shifts, on long shifts, after shifts, during night shifts, and on non-working days. Our data suggests that DNs prioritise their clinical responsibilities over their dietary intake at work. Consequently, they often miss eating opportunities and consume caffeine to stay alert during their shifts. Furthermore, DNs viewed night shifts as involving less healthy food choices. While participants expressed their intention to eat healthily during their shifts, their clinical responsibilities made maintaining regular and nutritious dietary practices throughout the day challenging. Nevertheless, DNs value their meal after a shift as the most important, as this could be the only meal they eat throughout the day.Our results suggest that DNs’ eating practices and dietary intake are sub-optimal to recommended dietary guidelines. It also suggests that eating practices are varied, individualised and not applicable to all, considering the many environmental and occupational factors contributing to DNs’ nutritional behaviours. Therefore, dietary workplace interventions are recommended to improve DNs’ dietary behaviours at work. Future research should explore DNs’ eating practices through follow-up interviews at various time points. This approach will provide valuable insights into DNs’ dietary and nutritional behaviours during shift work, helping to uncover additional barriers and challenges beyond DNs’ daily experiences.","PeriodicalId":20751,"journal":{"name":"Proceedings of the Nutrition Society","volume":"143 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":7.6000,"publicationDate":"2024-07-03","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Proceedings of the Nutrition Society","FirstCategoryId":"3","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1017/s0029665124004282","RegionNum":2,"RegionCategory":"医学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q1","JCRName":"NUTRITION & DIETETICS","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Doctors’ and nurses’ (DNs) wellbeing in the National Health Service is important for safe healthcare for those in need. However, their demanding duties, including irregular shift work, can significantly impact their health. Unfortunately, irregular working patterns are associated with higher sickness rates and stress among healthcare professionals due to the inherent challenges of the work(1,2). For example, shift work disrupts sleep and impairs cognitive function and performance, leading to poorer physiological and cardiovascular health(3), workforce shortages and difficulties adapting to a consistently demanding workload, which can impact patient care delivery(4). Despite the importance of workplace health and nutrition for DNs, our understanding of their dietary practices during shift work remains limited. Therefore, gaining insights into DNs’ eating habits during shifts is imperative to supporting their health. Our research aimed to understand DNs’ eating practices during their work, including the types of food consumed throughout the day.Online semi-structured interviews (n=16) were conducted with a convenience sample of current practising medical doctors (n=11) and nurses (n=5) in England. This provided an opportunity to compare and contrast the research data between DNs on workplace nutrition. All participants did shift work, encompassing varied working patterns, including day and night shifts, short and long days and weekends. Following Braun and Clarke’s(5) approach, an inductive thematic analysis presented the findings.Results elucidate six areas of DNs’ eating practices and dietary intake: before and during shifts, on long shifts, after shifts, during night shifts, and on non-working days. Our data suggests that DNs prioritise their clinical responsibilities over their dietary intake at work. Consequently, they often miss eating opportunities and consume caffeine to stay alert during their shifts. Furthermore, DNs viewed night shifts as involving less healthy food choices. While participants expressed their intention to eat healthily during their shifts, their clinical responsibilities made maintaining regular and nutritious dietary practices throughout the day challenging. Nevertheless, DNs value their meal after a shift as the most important, as this could be the only meal they eat throughout the day.Our results suggest that DNs’ eating practices and dietary intake are sub-optimal to recommended dietary guidelines. It also suggests that eating practices are varied, individualised and not applicable to all, considering the many environmental and occupational factors contributing to DNs’ nutritional behaviours. Therefore, dietary workplace interventions are recommended to improve DNs’ dietary behaviours at work. Future research should explore DNs’ eating practices through follow-up interviews at various time points. This approach will provide valuable insights into DNs’ dietary and nutritional behaviours during shift work, helping to uncover additional barriers and challenges beyond DNs’ daily experiences.
国家卫生服务部门的医生和护士(DNs)的健康对于为有需要的人提供安全的医疗保健服务非常重要。然而,他们繁重的工作,包括不规律的轮班工作,会严重影响他们的健康。不幸的是,由于工作本身的挑战性,不规则的工作模式与医护人员较高的患病率和压力有关(1,2)。例如,轮班工作会扰乱睡眠,损害认知功能和工作表现,导致生理和心血管健康状况恶化(3)、劳动力短缺以及难以适应持续繁重的工作量,从而影响患者护理服务的提供(4)。尽管工作场所的健康和营养对 DNs 十分重要,但我们对他们在轮班工作期间的饮食习惯的了解仍然有限。因此,深入了解 DNs 轮班期间的饮食习惯对于支持他们的健康至关重要。我们的研究旨在了解 DNs 工作期间的饮食习惯,包括一天中食用的食物类型。我们对英格兰的在职医生(11 人)和护士(5 人)进行了方便抽样的在线半结构式访谈(16 人)。这为比较和对比医生和护士在工作场所营养方面的研究数据提供了机会。所有参与者都从事轮班工作,工作模式多种多样,包括白班、夜班、长短日班和周末班。按照布劳恩和克拉克(Braun and Clarke)(5) 的方法,对研究结果进行了归纳式主题分析。结果阐明了 DNs 饮食习惯和饮食摄入的六个方面:班前和班中、长班、班后、夜班和非工作日。我们的数据表明,护士在工作中优先考虑的是临床职责,而不是饮食摄入。因此,他们经常错过进食机会,并在轮班期间摄入咖啡因以保持警觉。此外,DN 认为夜班期间选择的健康食品较少。虽然参与者表示希望在值班期间吃得健康,但他们的临床职责使全天保持规律和营养的饮食习惯具有挑战性。我们的研究结果表明,DN 的饮食习惯和膳食摄入量低于推荐的膳食指南。我们的研究结果表明,DNs 的饮食习惯和膳食摄入量未达到推荐膳食指南的最佳水平,这也表明,考虑到导致 DNs 营养行为的许多环境和职业因素,饮食习惯是多样的、个性化的,并不适用于所有人。因此,建议采取工作场所饮食干预措施,以改善 DNs 的工作饮食行为。未来的研究应通过不同时间点的跟踪访谈来探索 DNs 的饮食习惯。这种方法将为了解 DNs 在轮班工作期间的饮食和营养行为提供有价值的信息,有助于发现 DNs 日常经历之外的其他障碍和挑战。
期刊介绍:
Proceedings of the Nutrition Society publishes papers and abstracts presented by members and invited speakers at the scientific meetings of The Nutrition Society. The journal provides an invaluable record of the scientific research currently being undertaken, contributing to ''the scientific study of nutrition and its application to the maintenance of human and animal health.'' The journal is of interest to academics, researchers and clinical practice workers in both human and animal nutrition and related fields.