Phenotypic adaptation of Chironomus riparius to chronic Bti exposure: effects on emergence time and nutrient content

Abstract

Insects with aquatic larval and terrestrial adult life stages are a key component of coupled aquatic-terrestrial ecosystems. Thus, stressors applied to water bodies adversely affecting those larvae have the potential to influence the riparian zone through altered emergence, with differences in prey availability, timing, or nutrition. In this study, the common model organism Chironomus riparius, a species of Chironomidae (Diptera), was used. This selection was further motivated by its wide distribution in European freshwaters and its importance as prey for terrestrial predators. A stressor of high importance in this context is the globally used mosquito control agent Bacillus thuringiensis var. israelensis (Bti) which has been shown to affect Chironomidae. Here, we investigated the ability of chironomid populations to adapt to a regularly applied stressor, leading to a reduced impact of Bti. Therefore, the initial sensitivity of laboratory populations of C. riparius was investigated under the influence of field-relevant Bti treatments (three doses × two application days) and different food sources (high-quality TetraMin vs. low-quality Spirulina). Following a chronic exposure to Bti over six months, the sensitivity of pre-exposed and naïve populations was re-evaluated. Food quality had a strong impact on emergence timing and nutrient content. In addition, alterations in emergence time as well as protein and lipid contents of chronically exposed populations indicated a selection for individuals of advantageous energetics, potentially leading to a more efficient development while combating Bti. Signs of adaptation could be confirmed in five out of 36 tested scenarios suggesting adaptation to Bti at the population level. Adaptive responses of one or several species could theoretically (via eco-evolutionary dynamics) result in a community shift, favouring the prevalence of Bti-tolerant species. (In)direct effects of Bti and the adaptive responses at both population and community levels could affect higher trophic levels and may determine the fate of meta-ecosystems.