Tasks at hand or more challenges: The roles of regulatory focus and job insecurity in predicting work behaviours

Abstract

Previous studies have explored the effects of trait regulatory focus on routine performance and proactive behaviour yet failed to reveal the underlying motivational mechanisms and investigate how these effects may operate in uncertain environments. To fill this gap, our study first draws upon regulatory focus theory to examine the motivational mechanisms linking trait regulatory focus with routine performance and challenge-seeking behaviour (i.e., a type of proactive behaviour). We hypothesize that trait prevention focus improves routine performance but reduces challenge-seeking behaviour via avoidance motivation, whereas trait promotion focus increases routine performance and challenge-seeking behaviour through approach motivation. Incorporating trait activation theory, we further theorize that uncertainty that threatens individuals' security needs (i.e., quantitative job insecurity) strengthens trait prevention focus effects, while uncertainty that threatens individuals' growth needs (i.e., qualitative job insecurity) weakens trait promotion focus effects. Analysing two-wave data from 275 employees and 58 supervisors, we found that (a) trait prevention focus had an unconditional positive indirect effect on employee self-reported routine performance via increased avoidance motivation and (b) trait promotion focus had positive indirect effects on employee self-reported and supervisor-rated routine performance and challenge-seeking behaviour via enhanced approach motivation, with these effects stronger at lower levels of qualitative job insecurity.