Geometric morphometric analysis of beak shape of Columbimorphae (Columbas, Van, Mardin and Dönek)

Abstract

Selective breeding over centuries has led to the emergence of numerous pigeon breeds from the single species Columba livia, showcasing unparalleled phenotypic diversity. In Eastern Turkey, Van pigeons originate, while Tumbler pigeon varieties thrive countrywide, reflecting local traditions. The avian beak, vital for survival, offers insights into domestication and traits influenced by natural selection. Geometric morphometrics, a shape analysis method, allows for a comprehensive examination of beak shapes among domestic pigeons, providing a nuanced understanding of their complexity. Understanding beak diversity in pigeons, especially those found in Turkey, enhances our knowledge of avian evolution and adaptation processes. The study utilized 48 skulls from 4 pigeon breeds, including wild rock pigeons and domestic pigeons of Tumbler, Mardin and Van breeds, all free from pathological lesions and adults. Geometric morphometric analyses of beak shape were conducted using dorsal and lateral photographs, with landmarks placed using tpsDig software. MorphoJ software facilitated procrustes analysis and principal component analysis (PCA) to assess morphological variability and differentiate pigeon breeds based on shape patterns, with significance set at p < 0.05. PCA revealed significant shape variations among pigeon breeds, with 47 principal components identified for lateral beak views and 36 principal components for dorsal views. Canonical variates analysis further distinguished morphological patterns among breeds, indicating distinct shape variations in both dorsal and lateral views, elucidating the unique characteristics of each breed's beak morphology. Our results demonstrate statistically significant differences in pigeon beak shape, particularly in the lateral view, confirming the importance of these variations (p < 0.05) and suggesting that such differences occur less than 5% of the time under the null hypothesis.