Disentangling the veil line for Brazilian biodiversity: An overview from two long-term research programs reveals huge gaps in ecological data reporting.
Aretha Franklin Guimaraes, Luciano Carramaschi de Alagao Querido, Taina Rocha, Domingos de Jesus Rodrigues, Pedro Lage Viana, Helena de Godoy Bergallo, Geraldo Wilson Fernandes, Tiago Shizen Pacheco Toma, Helena Streit, Gerhard Ernst Overbeck, Alberico Queiroz Salgueiro de Souza, Albertina Pimentel Lima, Clarissa Alves da Rosa, Carlos Eduardo de Viveiros Grelle, Alessandra Monteiro Lopes, Alexandre Curcino, Alexandre Souza de Paula, Aline Andriolo, Aline Dos Santos Dias, Aline Tavares Santos, Amanda Araujo Bernardes, Amanda Batista da Silva Oliveira, Ana Angelica Monteiro de Barros, Ana Carolina Borges Lins E Silva, Ana Carolina Rodrigues da Cruz, Ana Sofia Sousa de Holanda, Anderson Saldanha Bueno, Andre Felippe Nunes-Freitas, Andre Yves, Andreia da Silva Alencar, Andressa Barbara Scabin, Angelo Gilberto Manzatto, Antonio Cesar Silva Lima, Antonio Rossano Mendes Pontes, Arlison B Castro, Arthur Monteiro Gomes, Aureo Banhos, Bruno H P Rosado, Caio Augusto Dos Santos Batista, Carla Costa Siqueira, Carla Suertegaray Fontana, Carlos Frederico Duarte da Rocha, Carlos R Brocardo, Carolina Rodrigues da Costa Doria, Carolina Volkmer Castilho, Caroline Pessanha, Cesar A M M Cordeiro, Cecilia Cronemberger, Christian Borges Andretti, Cintia Cornelius, Ciro Campos, Clarice Borges-Matos, Claudia Franca Barros, Claudia Keller, Claymir de Oliveira Cavalcante, Cristian de Sales Dambros, Davi Nepomuceno da Silva Machado, Diego Tassinari, Dora Maria Villela, Eduardo Chiaraniv, Eduardo de Farias Geisler, Eduardo Velez-Martin, Elildo Alves Ribeiro Carvalho-Junior, Elisandro Ricardo Drechsler-Santos, Elizabete Captivo Lourenco, Elizabeth Franklin, Emilio Manabu Higashikawa, Flavia Pezzini, Fabio de Oliveira Roque, Fabricio Beggiato Baccaro, Fernando Gertum Becker, Fernando Goncalvez Cabeceira, Fernando do Prado Florencio, Flavia Rodrigues Barbosa, Flavia Pezzini, Gabriela Zuquim, Guilherme Braga Ferreira, Guilherme Krahl de Vargas, Guilherme Mourao, Guillaume Xavier Rousseau, Haroldo Cavalcante de Lima, Hugo Leonardo Sousa Farias, Igor Luis Kaefer, Ivo Rohling Ghizoni, Janaina da Costa de Noronha, Jaqueline Lopes de Oliveira, Jhonson Reginaldo Silva Santos, Joao Andre Jarenkow, Joao Carlos Ferreira de Melo-Junior, Joao Vitor Chave Dos Santos, Jocieli de Oliveira, Jorge Luiz Pereira de Souza, Jose Fernando Andrade Baumgratz, Jose Wellinton de Morais, Joyce de Melo Silva, Julia de Gois Silva, Juliana M Wingert, Juliana Menger, Juliano Ferrer, Jussara Santos Dayrell, Kelly Cristina da Silva-Goncalves, Kelly Torralvo, Kely da Silva Cruz, Lana da Silva Sylvestre, Leonor de Andrade Ribas, Leandro Dênis Battirola, Leticia Ramos, Leticia Rocha Caires, Lidiany Camila da Silva Carvalho, Lis Fernandes Stegmann, Lucelia Nobre Carvalho, Luciana da Silva Menezes, Luciana Moraes Costa, Luciana Regina Podgaiski, Luis Fabio Silveira, Luiz Roberto Malabarba, Marcelo Araujo Frangipani, Marcelo Tabarelli, Marcelo Trindade Nascimento, Marcia Cristina Mendes Marques, Marcia R Spies, Marco Antonio de Oliveira Dos Santos, Marcos Anaicy, Marcos Jose Salgado Vital, Marcos Silveira, Marcus Vinicius Vieira, Maria Aparecida de Moura Araujo, Maria Aurea Pinheiro de Almeida Silveira, Maria Fabiola Barros, Mariana Alves Faitanin, Mariana Iguatemy, Mariana Souza da Cunha, Mariana Moreira da Silva Murakami, Mariluce Rezende Messias, Marlucia Bonifacio Martins, Mateus Camana, Nadjara de Medeiros Correa, Nathan Castro Fonseca, Oscar Oswaldo Prieto-Benavides, Pablo J F Pena Rodrigues, Paloma Leal de Andrade, Pedro Aurelio Costa Lima Pequeno, Pedro Henrique Salomao Gananca, Pedro Paulo da Silva Ferreira, Poliana Cristina Rodrigues de Andrade, Priscila Alencar Azarak, Rafael de Fraga, Rafael M Rabelo, Raylanne de Lima Santos, Reinaldo Imbrozio Barbosa, Renato Bolson Dala-Corte, Ricardo Eduardo Vicente, Ricardo de Oliveira Perdiz, Rodrigo Paulo da Cunha Araujo, Ricardo Teixeira Gregorio de Andrade, Rita de Cassia Quitete Portela, Rodrigo Fadini, Rodrigo Machado Feitosa, Rosangela Santa-Brigida, Rui Cerqueira, Sandra Cristina Muller, Sergio Santorelli, Sonia Barbosa Dos Santos, Sonia Zanini Cechin, Stefano Spiteri Avilla, Susamar Pansini, Susan Aragon, Taina da Silva Figueiredo, Tainara Venturini Sobroza, Tais de Fatima Ramos Guimaraes, Talitha Ferreira Dos Santos, Thaise Emilio, Thiago de Azevedo Amorim, Thiago Izzo, Thadeu Sogral, Tiago Gomes Dos Santos, Timothy Lee Vincent, Tomas de Lima Rocha, Valerio D Pillar, Vanessa Pontes Mesquita, Vinicius Duncan Silva, Vitor Melo Erse Cyrino, Vitor Nelson Teixeira Borges-Junior, Viviane Maria Guedes Layme, Wendarlem Galvao Mota, Wenderson Nunes Santos, William Drose, Williamar Rodrigues Silva, William E Magnusson
{"title":"Disentangling the veil line for Brazilian biodiversity: An overview from two long-term research programs reveals huge gaps in ecological data reporting.","authors":"Aretha Franklin Guimaraes, Luciano Carramaschi de Alagao Querido, Taina Rocha, Domingos de Jesus Rodrigues, Pedro Lage Viana, Helena de Godoy Bergallo, Geraldo Wilson Fernandes, Tiago Shizen Pacheco Toma, Helena Streit, Gerhard Ernst Overbeck, Alberico Queiroz Salgueiro de Souza, Albertina Pimentel Lima, Clarissa Alves da Rosa, Carlos Eduardo de Viveiros Grelle, Alessandra Monteiro Lopes, Alexandre Curcino, Alexandre Souza de Paula, Aline Andriolo, Aline Dos Santos Dias, Aline Tavares Santos, Amanda Araujo Bernardes, Amanda Batista da Silva Oliveira, Ana Angelica Monteiro de Barros, Ana Carolina Borges Lins E Silva, Ana Carolina Rodrigues da Cruz, Ana Sofia Sousa de Holanda, Anderson Saldanha Bueno, Andre Felippe Nunes-Freitas, Andre Yves, Andreia da Silva Alencar, Andressa Barbara Scabin, Angelo Gilberto Manzatto, Antonio Cesar Silva Lima, Antonio Rossano Mendes Pontes, Arlison B Castro, Arthur Monteiro Gomes, Aureo Banhos, Bruno H P Rosado, Caio Augusto Dos Santos Batista, Carla Costa Siqueira, Carla Suertegaray Fontana, Carlos Frederico Duarte da Rocha, Carlos R Brocardo, Carolina Rodrigues da Costa Doria, Carolina Volkmer Castilho, Caroline Pessanha, Cesar A M M Cordeiro, Cecilia Cronemberger, Christian Borges Andretti, Cintia Cornelius, Ciro Campos, Clarice Borges-Matos, Claudia Franca Barros, Claudia Keller, Claymir de Oliveira Cavalcante, Cristian de Sales Dambros, Davi Nepomuceno da Silva Machado, Diego Tassinari, Dora Maria Villela, Eduardo Chiaraniv, Eduardo de Farias Geisler, Eduardo Velez-Martin, Elildo Alves Ribeiro Carvalho-Junior, Elisandro Ricardo Drechsler-Santos, Elizabete Captivo Lourenco, Elizabeth Franklin, Emilio Manabu Higashikawa, Flavia Pezzini, Fabio de Oliveira Roque, Fabricio Beggiato Baccaro, Fernando Gertum Becker, Fernando Goncalvez Cabeceira, Fernando do Prado Florencio, Flavia Rodrigues Barbosa, Flavia Pezzini, Gabriela Zuquim, Guilherme Braga Ferreira, Guilherme Krahl de Vargas, Guilherme Mourao, Guillaume Xavier Rousseau, Haroldo Cavalcante de Lima, Hugo Leonardo Sousa Farias, Igor Luis Kaefer, Ivo Rohling Ghizoni, Janaina da Costa de Noronha, Jaqueline Lopes de Oliveira, Jhonson Reginaldo Silva Santos, Joao Andre Jarenkow, Joao Carlos Ferreira de Melo-Junior, Joao Vitor Chave Dos Santos, Jocieli de Oliveira, Jorge Luiz Pereira de Souza, Jose Fernando Andrade Baumgratz, Jose Wellinton de Morais, Joyce de Melo Silva, Julia de Gois Silva, Juliana M Wingert, Juliana Menger, Juliano Ferrer, Jussara Santos Dayrell, Kelly Cristina da Silva-Goncalves, Kelly Torralvo, Kely da Silva Cruz, Lana da Silva Sylvestre, Leonor de Andrade Ribas, Leandro Dênis Battirola, Leticia Ramos, Leticia Rocha Caires, Lidiany Camila da Silva Carvalho, Lis Fernandes Stegmann, Lucelia Nobre Carvalho, Luciana da Silva Menezes, Luciana Moraes Costa, Luciana Regina Podgaiski, Luis Fabio Silveira, Luiz Roberto Malabarba, Marcelo Araujo Frangipani, Marcelo Tabarelli, Marcelo Trindade Nascimento, Marcia Cristina Mendes Marques, Marcia R Spies, Marco Antonio de Oliveira Dos Santos, Marcos Anaicy, Marcos Jose Salgado Vital, Marcos Silveira, Marcus Vinicius Vieira, Maria Aparecida de Moura Araujo, Maria Aurea Pinheiro de Almeida Silveira, Maria Fabiola Barros, Mariana Alves Faitanin, Mariana Iguatemy, Mariana Souza da Cunha, Mariana Moreira da Silva Murakami, Mariluce Rezende Messias, Marlucia Bonifacio Martins, Mateus Camana, Nadjara de Medeiros Correa, Nathan Castro Fonseca, Oscar Oswaldo Prieto-Benavides, Pablo J F Pena Rodrigues, Paloma Leal de Andrade, Pedro Aurelio Costa Lima Pequeno, Pedro Henrique Salomao Gananca, Pedro Paulo da Silva Ferreira, Poliana Cristina Rodrigues de Andrade, Priscila Alencar Azarak, Rafael de Fraga, Rafael M Rabelo, Raylanne de Lima Santos, Reinaldo Imbrozio Barbosa, Renato Bolson Dala-Corte, Ricardo Eduardo Vicente, Ricardo de Oliveira Perdiz, Rodrigo Paulo da Cunha Araujo, Ricardo Teixeira Gregorio de Andrade, Rita de Cassia Quitete Portela, Rodrigo Fadini, Rodrigo Machado Feitosa, Rosangela Santa-Brigida, Rui Cerqueira, Sandra Cristina Muller, Sergio Santorelli, Sonia Barbosa Dos Santos, Sonia Zanini Cechin, Stefano Spiteri Avilla, Susamar Pansini, Susan Aragon, Taina da Silva Figueiredo, Tainara Venturini Sobroza, Tais de Fatima Ramos Guimaraes, Talitha Ferreira Dos Santos, Thaise Emilio, Thiago de Azevedo Amorim, Thiago Izzo, Thadeu Sogral, Tiago Gomes Dos Santos, Timothy Lee Vincent, Tomas de Lima Rocha, Valerio D Pillar, Vanessa Pontes Mesquita, Vinicius Duncan Silva, Vitor Melo Erse Cyrino, Vitor Nelson Teixeira Borges-Junior, Viviane Maria Guedes Layme, Wendarlem Galvao Mota, Wenderson Nunes Santos, William Drose, Williamar Rodrigues Silva, William E Magnusson","doi":"10.1016/j.scitotenv.2024.174880","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p><p>The lack of synthesized information regarding biodiversity is a major problem among researchers, leading to a pervasive cycle where ecologists make field campaigns to collect information that already exists and yet has not been made available for a broader audience. This problem leads to long-lasting effects in public policies such as spending money multiple times to conduct similar studies in the same area. We aim to identify this knowledge gap by synthesizing information available regarding two Brazilian long-term biodiversity programs and the metadata generated by them. Using a unique dataset containing 1904 metadata, we identified patterns of metadata distribution and intensity of research conducted in Brazil, as well as where we should concentrate research efforts in the next decades. We found that the majority of metadata were about vertebrates, followed by plants, invertebrates, and fungi. Caatinga was the biome with least metadata, and that there's still a lack of information regarding all biomes in Brazil, with none of them being sufficiently sampled. We hope that these results will have implications for broader conservation and management guiding, as well as to funding allocation programs.</p>","PeriodicalId":422,"journal":{"name":"Science of the Total Environment","volume":null,"pages":null},"PeriodicalIF":8.2000,"publicationDate":"2024-11-10","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Science of the Total Environment","FirstCategoryId":"93","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2024.174880","RegionNum":1,"RegionCategory":"环境科学与生态学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"2024/7/23 0:00:00","PubModel":"Epub","JCR":"Q1","JCRName":"ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
The lack of synthesized information regarding biodiversity is a major problem among researchers, leading to a pervasive cycle where ecologists make field campaigns to collect information that already exists and yet has not been made available for a broader audience. This problem leads to long-lasting effects in public policies such as spending money multiple times to conduct similar studies in the same area. We aim to identify this knowledge gap by synthesizing information available regarding two Brazilian long-term biodiversity programs and the metadata generated by them. Using a unique dataset containing 1904 metadata, we identified patterns of metadata distribution and intensity of research conducted in Brazil, as well as where we should concentrate research efforts in the next decades. We found that the majority of metadata were about vertebrates, followed by plants, invertebrates, and fungi. Caatinga was the biome with least metadata, and that there's still a lack of information regarding all biomes in Brazil, with none of them being sufficiently sampled. We hope that these results will have implications for broader conservation and management guiding, as well as to funding allocation programs.
期刊介绍：
The Science of the Total Environment is an international journal dedicated to scientific research on the environment and its interaction with humanity. It covers a wide range of disciplines and seeks to publish innovative, hypothesis-driven, and impactful research that explores the entire environment, including the atmosphere, lithosphere, hydrosphere, biosphere, and anthroposphere.
The journal's updated Aims & Scope emphasizes the importance of interdisciplinary environmental research with broad impact. Priority is given to studies that advance fundamental understanding and explore the interconnectedness of multiple environmental spheres. Field studies are preferred, while laboratory experiments must demonstrate significant methodological advancements or mechanistic insights with direct relevance to the environment.
京公网安备 11010802042870号
京ICP备2023020795号-1
分享
求助内容：
应助结果提醒方式：
扫码关注我们
