Development and validation of a method to generate phenol red thread tests

Abstract

Purpose

The aim of this study was to develop and validate a method to generate phenol red thread tests (PRTT) due to the lack of availability of commercial PRTT.

Methods

White cotton thread was dyed with phenol red (pH indicator) for 48 h, dried, cut, and sterilized. To validate its wicking ability, the thread was inserted into solutions of varying pH, flanking the pH of healthy tears, for different time intervals. To assess its diagnostic utility, PRTTs were performed in vivo on wildtype and a murine model of evaporative dry eye, acyl-coA: wax alcohol acyltransferase 2 knockout (Awat2 KO) mice.

Results

Two batches of PRTT were produced that had a similar appearance and function to the commercial product. In vitro testing revealed no significant differences in the wicking kinetics at any time point across the pH solutions for batch 1 and only one difference for batch 2 (pH 7.4 vs 7.8 at 5 s, P = 0.029). When comparing both batches, similar wicking kinetics were found with only two significant differences identified (pH 7.6 at 40 s and pH 7.8 at 35 s, P < 0.01). In vivo, our PRTT yielded similar measurements to the commercial PRTT in wildtype and Awat2 KO mice and detected a significant increase in aqueous tear volume in the Awat2 KO mice (commercial: P = 0.015, our PRTT: P = 0.002).

Conclusion

Our method provides a reproducible diagnostic test that performs similarly to its commercial counterpart in a relevant dry eye model indicating that it can serve as a valid and reliable replacement.