Feather carotenoids of the American Redstart (Setophaga ruticilla) across age and sex classes and the reliability of standard color metrics to capture pigment variation

Abstract

Plumage ornaments act as important sexual signals, though the extent to which these ornaments act as honest signals—and the physiological mechanisms that maintain honesty—remain poorly understood. We studied the pigmentary basis of tail color in the American Redstart (Setophaga ruticilla), a species of songbird with sexual dichromatism and delayed plumage maturation; younger males resemble females, only replacing their yellow feathers for bright orange ones after the first breeding season. The yellow rectrices of females and young males and the orange feathers of older males largely contain the same pigments, but in vastly different proportions. Whereas the feathers of females and young males contain primarily lutein, 3′-dehydro-lutein and canary-xanthophylls, those of older males contain primarily 4-keto-carotenoids. The presence of lutein and the predominance of α-doradexanthin as 4-keto-carotenoid, a pigment with a shortened chain of conjugated double bonds compared to keto-carotenoids commonly found in red feathers, in the feathers of older males contribute to their uncommon orange hue. Since the orange coloration of the tail in the American redstart results from the combination of yellow, orange, and red pigments, this is a system where slight adjustments in the types of carotenoids deposited could significantly alter hue. Factors either work against achieving the most oxidized state in this species or the hue is maintained through stabilizing selection for a favored color. The color metrics of Carotenoid Chroma, Visible Hue, λ_R50 and tetrahedral θ best captured differences in pigment concentration and make-up, and are recommended in future spectrophotometric studies of carotenoid-based traits.