Extensive restoration of the entire habitat complex is key to the successful recovery of threatened species: The case of the natterjack toad Epidalea calamita at the northern range margin

Abstract

Increasing concerns about biodiversity loss have prompted international efforts to restore degraded habitats. Unfortunately, wildlife habitat restoration often fails due to inadequate planning, inappropriate scale, or lack of providing key elements of habitats. We investigated the effectiveness of habitat restoration of a threatened amphibian species, the natterjack toad Epidalea calamita, in Estonia, comparing two different restoration approaches – partial habitat restoration and extensive habitat restoration over 16 years. Our goal was to investigate the impact of these two different approaches on the populations, to find out which habitat components play a key role in restoration and which measures are of primary importance in the restoration of habitats for small amphibian populations. We used GIS analysis to identify changes in the area of the habitat complex and breeding sites in seven natterjack toad locations following the restoration activities. To assess population response to habitat restoration, we used the census of the natterjack toad egg-strings as a proxy to the population size. The average number of egg-strings increased by 1.2-fold after partial habitat restoration and 3.5-fold when comparing partial habitat restoration with extensive restoration. Partial habitat restoration, which consisted of improving the condition of extant habitat, had no significant effect on population size (number of egg-strings), while extensive habitat restoration, which included improving and enlarging the entire habitat complex (both terrestrial and aquatic habitats as well as migration matrix between these components) led to population growth. The habitat features that positively influenced population growth were the area of entire habitat complex and the number and size of the breeding sites. In terms of habitat restoration and conservation measures, the number of natterjack toad populations was positively affected by restoration of the entire habitat complex (terrestrial habitats and water bodies), which was supplemented by the supportive rearing of tadpoles.