A critical assessment of the diatom test of rib bone marrow as a supporting procedure in the case of drowning

Abstract

Diatoms (Bacillariophyta), being single-celled photosynthetic organisms, are widely distributed in aquatic ecosystems around the globe. Their exoskeletons are resistant to most environmental factors as well as chemical reagents in laboratory settings. Moreover, the ornamentation featured on exoskeletons can be used to identify individual diatomaceous species. As a result, the detection of diatoms in the internal organs, and especially rib marrow, of corpses found in water can serve as an important tool for diagnosing drowning as the cause of death as long as passive postmortem penetration of diatoms into those organs is excluded. In the environmental experiments described in this paper, diatoms were detected in rib marrow only when contamination resulted from a mechanical breach of bone integrity and structure, irrespective of the residence time of bone material in the aquatic environment. Our research suggests that the presence of diatom in the rib marrow may be the gold standard in the diagnosis of drowning in the future. Our animal model research dispels one of the doubts, such as the possibility of passive penetration of diatoms into the bone marrow, which is still under discussion in the forensic medicine community.