An evaluation of the diagnostic performance of the triphasic bone scintigraphy in patients suspected of aseptic total knee arthroplasty loosening

Abstract

Background

Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) is a widely conducted and successful orthopedic procedure. However, aseptic loosening, a common cause of TKA failure, necessitates revision surgery. Diagnostic accuracy of triphasic bone scintigraphy, a common imaging modality for aseptic loosening detection, remains controversial. This study investigated the diagnostic accuracy of bone scintigraphy when separately evaluated by a nuclear physicist and an orthopedic surgeon, and the interrater reliability between the two.

Methods

Patients undergoing knee revision surgery due to suspected aseptic loosening at three medical centers from 2006 to 2023 were included. Relevant demographic, clinical, and procedural data were extracted from the records. The bone scintigraphy results as noted by the nuclear physicist and orthopedic surgeon were used as index test and intraoperative findings of loosening were used as reference tests. Accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value were calculated, and kappa's agreement was assessed.

Results

Out of 611 revision TKAs, 59 cases were analyzed. The nuclear physicist's evaluation of bone scintigraphy had a sensitivity of 73 %, specificity of 0 %, positive predictive value of 93 %, negative predictive value of 0 %, and diagnostic accuracy of 69 %. The orthopedic surgeon's evaluation showed higher sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values, and an accuracy of 84 %. Agreement levels were moderate (kappa = 0.46) between the nuclear physicist's and orthopedic surgeons evaluation.

Interpretation

The diagnostic accuracy of bone scintigraphy for aseptic loosening is 84 % when evaluated by the orthopedic surgeon compared to 69 % for the nuclear physicist's evaluation. Kappa's agreement between the two was moderate.