Thousands of shallow, relict gullies indicate thermo-erosion on the sandy uplands of northern Lower Michigan during the Late Pleistocene

Abstract

We build on previous work which explained the origin of myriad gullies and incised channels on the dry, sandy uplands of northern Lower Michigan by invoking widespread permafrost. Indicators of permafrost (ice-wedge casts and patterned ground) are known from many sites across the region. Our study area, within an extensive reentrant of the retreating Laurentide Ice Sheet, had been particularly well positioned, geographically, for permafrost. Our goal was to characterize the geomorphic characteristics of the gullies on 72 large ridges, to address the hypothesis that they had formed in association with permafrost. Across the study area, thousands of dry, narrow channels and gullies occur in dense networks, typically with channels aligned directly downslope, in parallel drainage patterns. Most of the gullies exhibit only a minimal amount of incision (ca. 2–3 m), a nearly straight longitudinal profile, and lack a clear depositional fan at their mouth. Even where small fans are present, they are subtle and exhibit little down-fan textural sorting, as would be present in larger, more mature fluvial systems. Gully morphologies did not exhibit strong morphological differences as a function of aspect, as we would have expected for an erosional, periglacial system forming on fairly steep slopes. Nonetheless, in these sandy/gravelly sediments, we could find no other scenario that would have allowed for runoff and gully formation, except ice-rich permafrost that limited infiltration and promoted saturation of the active layer, and eventually, runoff. We conclude that the gullies formed via thermo-erosion into ice-rich permafrost, involving mostly fluvial processes but also some slope failure. Even though thermo-erosion can rapidly form deep gullies, our study area has mainly weak gully forms, perhaps because: (1) permafrost existed here only briefly, (2) the landscape was so cold and the permafrost so ice-rich that runoff was rare, (3) the permafrost on the sandy slopes remained somewhat permeable, limiting runoff, and/or (4) the paleoclimate was so dry that little water was available for sediment transport. We could find no evidence that the gullies developed within preexisting polygonal networks, as is happening today in polar regions under a warming climate. Thus, our study has implications for areas of the Arctic and Antarctic that are, today, experiencing rapid hydrological changes.