Rare Variants of DNA Ligase 1 Show Distinct Mechanisms of Deficiency.

Abstract

Human DNA ligase 1 (LIG1) performs the final step in DNA repair and recombination pathways by sealing DNA breaks, and it functions as the main replicative ligase. Hypomorphic LIG1 variants R771W and R641L cause immune deficiencies in LIG1 Syndrome patients. In vitro these LIG1 variants have decreased catalytic efficiency and increased abortive ligation and it is not known if either biochemical defect is sufficient on its own to cause immune deficiency. We investigated the enzymatic activity of several new candidate LIG1 Syndrome variants chosen based on their structural proximity to known clinical variants, low minor allele frequency (MAF), high level of conservation, and concurrence in patients with similar symptoms as LIG1 Syndrome patients. The R305Q substitution is in the DNA binding domain, R768W is in the OB-fold domain, and R641S is in the nucleotidyltransferase domain. Biochemical characterization confirmed deficiencies in ligase activity for all three variants, but also revealed marked differences in comparison to the known LIG1 Syndrome variants. Both the R305Q and R768W substitutions increase the K_M for DNA and decrease the catalytic efficiency, however, neither exhibit elevated levels of abortive ligation. In contrast, the R641S variant exhibits a greater impairment of activity as well as a more pronounced level of abortive ligation compared to the known LIG1 Syndrome variant, R641L. This work expands the number of LIG1 alleles that are likely candidates for LIG1 Syndrome, and it raises the question of whether distinct enzymatic deficiencies in LIG1 cause unique clinical impacts in patients harboring these alleles.