Thuy Minh Ha, Quang Thanh Nguyen, Siaw Cheok Liew, Jeffrey Mayne, Phuoc Van Le
{"title":"The transition to clerkshIps bootcamp: Innovative and flexible curriculum strategies post COVID-19 adaptation","authors":"Thuy Minh Ha, Quang Thanh Nguyen, Siaw Cheok Liew, Jeffrey Mayne, Phuoc Van Le","doi":"10.1111/medu.15573","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p>As <span>in</span> many other countries, Vietnam was severely affected by the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020 and 2021. The transition from traditional face-to-face instruction to remote learning amid social distancing measures propelled educators to develop new delivery methods to adapt to the new circumstances.<span><sup>1</sup></span> At VinUniversity, medical students experienced gaps in their clinical skills due to the shift to remote learning and deferred hands-on training. These gaps included insufficient exposure to hospital settings, challenges in interpersonal communication, limited opportunities for history-taking and physical examinations. These deficiencies necessitated the development of an intensive preparatory course to bridge these gaps before students entered their clerkships.</p><p>In response to the above situation, a 4-week “Transition to Clerkship Bootcamp” was implemented to equip the students with both knowledge and skills to overcome the disparity. This bootcamp was organized in the summer of the pre-clerkship year, comprising three main themes: (i) Introduction to Clinical Medicine, focusing on refining skills in history-taking, physical examination and communication; (ii) Hospital Preparation, providing practical training in hospital orientation, infection control and patient care; and (iii) Differential Diagnosis, emphasizing symptom-based diagnosis. The course summative assessment, including case presentations of actual patients seen during hospital visits (30%), completion of illness scripts (30%) and an Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) exam (40%), established a baseline for evaluating students' readiness for clerkships.</p><p>In its inaugural implementation, 49 students completed the bootcamp, with an 85.7% response rate to the course-end survey. The course received a mean satisfaction score of 4.2 out of 5 on Likert scale, indicating a significant increase in students' confidence and preparedness for their clerkships.</p><p>The Transition to Clerkship Bootcamp addressed important gaps in medical education imposed by remote learning during the pandemic, including clinical skills such as physical examination and communication, as well as clinical reasoning in the differential diagnosis modules leading to high performance on the OSCE, written examination of illness scripts and feedback from students on course evaluations. However, several key insights emerged from the implementation process. First, the lowest evaluation grade, mean 4.1 out of 5, was given to the course workload due to the intensive coverage of three themes within a 4-week period. This suggests a need for balancing content delivery with manageable student workload. Second, qualitative feedback revealed student concerns regarding the fairness and clarity of assessments, particularly due to limited familiarity with certain evaluation methods. One of the most valuable lessons learned was the importance of faculty development in the success of such an intensive program. Clinical preceptors played an essential role in shaping the curriculum, aligning hospital preparation modules with real-world clinical settings and providing students with practical exposure to clinical environments. However, the experience highlighted the need for structured faculty development programs that prepare instructors not only to deliver content but also to mentor students effectively. As many of the preceptors were relatively new to teaching in a bootcamp format, it became evident that faculty training should include guidance on active learning strategies, assessment calibration and providing constructive feedback to students.</p><p>In conclusion, the successful integration of the bootcamp into the medical curriculum has provided a model for not only for facilitating the transition to clerkship but also for addressing post-pandemic educational challenges in clinical training, with potential applications in other settings where similar disruptions have occurred.</p><p><b>Thuy Minh Ha:</b> Conceptualization; writing—original draft; methodology; project administration. <b>Quang Thanh Nguyen:</b> Conceptualization; investigation; writing—original draft. <b>Siaw Cheok Liew:</b> Conceptualization; methodology. <b>Jeffrey Mayne:</b> Investigation; data curation; supervision. <b>Phuoc Van Le:</b> Conceptualization; supervision; project administration.</p>","PeriodicalId":18370,"journal":{"name":"Medical Education","volume":"59 2","pages":"232-233"},"PeriodicalIF":5.2000,"publicationDate":"2024-11-17","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/medu.15573","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Medical Education","FirstCategoryId":"95","ListUrlMain":"https://asmepublications.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/medu.15573","RegionNum":1,"RegionCategory":"教育学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q1","JCRName":"EDUCATION, SCIENTIFIC DISCIPLINES","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
As in many other countries, Vietnam was severely affected by the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020 and 2021. The transition from traditional face-to-face instruction to remote learning amid social distancing measures propelled educators to develop new delivery methods to adapt to the new circumstances.1 At VinUniversity, medical students experienced gaps in their clinical skills due to the shift to remote learning and deferred hands-on training. These gaps included insufficient exposure to hospital settings, challenges in interpersonal communication, limited opportunities for history-taking and physical examinations. These deficiencies necessitated the development of an intensive preparatory course to bridge these gaps before students entered their clerkships.
In response to the above situation, a 4-week “Transition to Clerkship Bootcamp” was implemented to equip the students with both knowledge and skills to overcome the disparity. This bootcamp was organized in the summer of the pre-clerkship year, comprising three main themes: (i) Introduction to Clinical Medicine, focusing on refining skills in history-taking, physical examination and communication; (ii) Hospital Preparation, providing practical training in hospital orientation, infection control and patient care; and (iii) Differential Diagnosis, emphasizing symptom-based diagnosis. The course summative assessment, including case presentations of actual patients seen during hospital visits (30%), completion of illness scripts (30%) and an Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) exam (40%), established a baseline for evaluating students' readiness for clerkships.
In its inaugural implementation, 49 students completed the bootcamp, with an 85.7% response rate to the course-end survey. The course received a mean satisfaction score of 4.2 out of 5 on Likert scale, indicating a significant increase in students' confidence and preparedness for their clerkships.
The Transition to Clerkship Bootcamp addressed important gaps in medical education imposed by remote learning during the pandemic, including clinical skills such as physical examination and communication, as well as clinical reasoning in the differential diagnosis modules leading to high performance on the OSCE, written examination of illness scripts and feedback from students on course evaluations. However, several key insights emerged from the implementation process. First, the lowest evaluation grade, mean 4.1 out of 5, was given to the course workload due to the intensive coverage of three themes within a 4-week period. This suggests a need for balancing content delivery with manageable student workload. Second, qualitative feedback revealed student concerns regarding the fairness and clarity of assessments, particularly due to limited familiarity with certain evaluation methods. One of the most valuable lessons learned was the importance of faculty development in the success of such an intensive program. Clinical preceptors played an essential role in shaping the curriculum, aligning hospital preparation modules with real-world clinical settings and providing students with practical exposure to clinical environments. However, the experience highlighted the need for structured faculty development programs that prepare instructors not only to deliver content but also to mentor students effectively. As many of the preceptors were relatively new to teaching in a bootcamp format, it became evident that faculty training should include guidance on active learning strategies, assessment calibration and providing constructive feedback to students.
In conclusion, the successful integration of the bootcamp into the medical curriculum has provided a model for not only for facilitating the transition to clerkship but also for addressing post-pandemic educational challenges in clinical training, with potential applications in other settings where similar disruptions have occurred.
与许多其他国家一样,越南在2020年和2021年受到COVID-19大流行的严重影响。在社会距离措施下,从传统的面对面教学向远程学习的转变促使教育工作者开发新的教学方法来适应新的情况在VinUniversity,由于转向远程学习和推迟实践培训,医学生的临床技能出现了差距。这些差距包括接触医院环境不足、人际沟通困难、记录病史和体检机会有限。这些不足需要在学生进入实习岗位之前开设一个密集的预备课程来弥补这些差距。针对上述情况,我们实施了为期四周的“过渡见习营”,让学员掌握知识和技能,以克服这种差距。这个训练营是在办事员前一年的夏季举办的,包括三个主题:(i)临床医学导论,重点是提高记录病史、体格检查和交流方面的技能;㈡医院准备,提供医院情况介绍、感染控制和病人护理方面的实际培训;(三)鉴别诊断,强调症状诊断。课程总结性评估,包括在医院就诊期间实际患者的病例介绍(30%),完成疾病处方(30%)和客观结构化临床检查(OSCE)考试(40%),为评估学生的见习准备情况建立了基线。在首次实施中,49名学生完成了训练营,课程结束时的调查回复率为85.7%。在李克特量表上,该课程的平均满意度得分为4.2分(满分5分),这表明学生对自己的见习工作的信心和准备有了显著的提高。向见习培训营过渡解决了大流行病期间远程学习给医学教育造成的重大差距,包括临床技能,如体检和沟通,以及鉴别诊断模块中的临床推理,从而在欧安组织取得高绩效,对病状进行书面考试,以及学生对课程评价的反馈。然而,从实施过程中产生了几个关键的见解。首先,由于在4周的时间内密集覆盖了三个主题,因此课程工作量获得了最低的评价分数,平均为4.1分(满分为5分)。这表明需要平衡内容交付和可管理的学生工作量。其次,定性反馈揭示了学生对评估的公平性和清晰度的关注,特别是由于对某些评估方法的熟悉程度有限。我学到的最有价值的经验之一是,在这样一个密集项目的成功中,教师发展的重要性。临床导师在课程设置中发挥了至关重要的作用,使医院准备模块与现实世界的临床环境保持一致,并为学生提供临床环境的实际接触。然而,这一经历凸显了有组织的教师发展计划的必要性,这些计划不仅使教师能够提供内容,而且还能有效地指导学生。由于许多教师对训练营形式的教学相对陌生,很明显,教师培训应该包括对主动学习策略的指导,评估校准和向学生提供建设性反馈。最后,将训练营成功地纳入医学课程,不仅为促进向办案人员的过渡提供了一种模式,而且还为解决大流行后临床培训中的教育挑战提供了一种模式,并有可能应用于发生类似中断的其他环境。徐明河:概念化;原创作品草案;方法;项目管理。Quang Thanh Nguyen:概念化;调查;原创作品。萧卓:概念化;方法。杰弗里·梅恩:调查;数据管理;监督。phouc Van Le:概念化;监督;项目管理。
期刊介绍:
Medical Education seeks to be the pre-eminent journal in the field of education for health care professionals, and publishes material of the highest quality, reflecting world wide or provocative issues and perspectives.
The journal welcomes high quality papers on all aspects of health professional education including;
-undergraduate education
-postgraduate training
-continuing professional development
-interprofessional education