The amendment value of pulp and paper mill sludges in Finnish coarse-textured soil

Abstract

As a source of exogenous organic matter, pulp and/or paper mill sludges (PPMS) may have beneficial effects on crop productivity and soil chemical and physical properties. This study's aim was to assess the impacts of two different PPMS materials on crop yields, the quality of percolation water, and soil chemical and hydraulic properties in a three-year field experiment on a silt loam soil in East Central Finland. Fresh (FPMS) and lime-stabilized (LPMS) sludges were applied once at rates of 21–28 fresh-Mg ha⁻¹ in the spring prior to the sowing of grass ley under barley as a cover crop and incorporated into the upper 7 cm soil layer. Supplemental nitrogen (N) was applied at levels of 40 and 80 kg ha⁻¹. A decrease of barley grain yield due to N immobilization was observed at the N level 40 kg ha⁻¹, but the standard N application rate (80 kg ha⁻¹) connected with a moderate C:N ratio (FPMS 27:1, LPMS 24:1) was adequate to avoid significant yield losses. In the second and third year following the PPMS applications, there was a tendency for positive residual effects on the total dry matter yield of grass ley, which could be attributed to slow mineralization of sludge-N. The application of LPMS increased the pH in surface soil by 0.5–0.7-units and Ca concentration by 240–660 mg L⁻¹ of soil relative to the non-amended control over the study period. In the year of PPMS applications, the amendments produced a significant increase (about 2.0 g kg⁻¹) in the total carbon (C) concentrations in the uppermost 10 cm soil layer relative to the non-amended soil. During the following years, the change in soil C was no longer measurable, indicating relatively fast decomposition of sludge-C. Saturated hydraulic conductivity tended to be 1.4 to 2.3 times higher in the PPMS-treated soils than in the non-amended soil. Except for the decline in readily plant-available water, the other common water retention parameters were not significantly affected by the PPMS amendments. There were significant positive treatment effects on the amount of water retained between −13 and − 316 kPa matric potentials, suggesting an increase in medium-sized pores contributing to water storage in the soil. To maintain or enhance the beneficial direct and indirect effects of PPMS on crop yields and soil physico-chemical properties, repeated applications of PPMS are required, possibly combined with the use of organic fertilizers, especially during grass ley years.