The Trojan Horse of Kidney Transplantation Returns: A Review and Call for Financial Neutrality

Abstract

ebate over payments to donors is discussed with particular emphasis on the national and international ramifications of such payments, the impact on normative “altruistic” donation, and the nature of the relationship between the doctor and the patient in the donor work up process. A way forward is proposed through the promotion of “Financial Neutrality” and expanded efforts to prevent chronic kidney disease. Publications in both the lay and academic press suggest that the problem of long waiting lists for deceased donor kidney transplants could be solved if only the National Organ Transplant Act (NOTA) were changed to permit various forms of financial incentives to kidney donors. The history of the debate over payments to donors is discussed with particular emphasis on the national and international ramifications of such payments, the impact on normative “altruistic” donation, and the nature of the relationship between the doctor and the patient in the donor work up process. A way forward is proposed through the promotion of “Financial Neutrality” and expanded efforts to prevent chronic kidney disease. Copyright © 2024 by the American Society of Nephrology...