Cross-Calibration of Areal Bone Mineral Densities and Body Composition between DMS Stratos and Hologic Horizon A Dual-Energy X-ray Absorptiometers: The Effect of Body Mass Index

Abstract

Purpose: The aim of this study was to investigate the correlations between areal bone mineral density (aBMD) and body composition measured by two dual-energy X-ray absorptiometers (DXA), the DMS Stratos® (STR) and the Hologic Horizon A® (HRZ), and then generate cross-calibration equations between the two scanners.

Methods: Repeat scans were obtained from 251 adults (85 % female), 36 ± 14 years old with mean body mass index (BMI) of 28.7 ± 11.1 kg/m2, using HRZ (fan-beam technology) and STR (pencil-beam technology). aBMD was measured at whole body [WB], femoral neck [FN], total hip [TH], lumbar spine [LS] and radius, while fat mass [FM] and lean tissue mass [LTM] were determined at whole body and at android and gynoid subregions.

Results: Compared to HRZ, STR underestimated both aBMD at WB and radius and LTM at WB and android and gynoid regions. Conversely, STR overestimated aBMD at FN, TH, LS and FM at WB android and gynoid regions. Except for WB bone mineral content (r = 0.87) and WB aBMD (r = 0.84), there were strong correlations of aBMD and body composition between the two DXAs (r > 0.91; p < 0.0001). Several of the parameters that required the determination of specific cross-calibration equations because of the significant bias between the two DXAs were found to be influenced by BMI.

Conclusions: Although the data from the STR and the HRZ were highly correlated for aBMD and body composition parameters, a systematic measurement bias between two DXAs was observed. The development of cross-calibration equations fully corrected these differences and they may thus be useful for multicenter studies when scans are performed with STR and HRZ.