Impact of 3D Endovision System on Learning Process of Laparoscopic Transabdominal Preperitoneal Repair of Groin Hernia.

Abstract

Background: Laparo-endoscopic hernia surgery is recommended by various international bodies. However, its uptake by general surgeon is low. We aim to assess the impact of Three Dimensional (3D) endovision system in learning laparoscopic transabdominal preperitoneal (TAPP) repair of groin hernia and transferability of skills acquired from 3D to the Two Dimensional (2D) environment. Methodology: Senior resident doctor with no previous experience in laparoscopic hernia surgery did 20 consecutive cases of TAPP repair using 3D endovision system followed by another five cases of TAPP repair using 2D endovision system. Total operating time, operating time during different phases of hernia surgery, faculty take over time, path length of needle holder, and scissors were recorded. Cumulative sum (CUSUM) and split group analysis were done to assess the learning process. Trainee's operating time was compared with that of experts' from previously published study of the same group. Data were compared between last block of five cases done using 3D system and cases done using 2D system for skill transferability. Results: CUSUM method provided inflection points of total operating time, hernia dissection and mesh placement at 9th case, and peritoneal suturing at 11th case in learning TAPP hernia. After 10th case, trainee's operating time was within the middle 50 percentage of experts operating time. Total operating time in last block of cases done under 3D vision and that of 2D endovision comparable, although peritoneal closure was significantly longer in 2D vision (P = .074, .2, .145, .001). Conclusion: Reduction on operating time appears after ninth case of TAPP hernia repair using the 3D endovision system. The skills acquired under 3D endovision system are transferable to perform the procedure under 2D endovision system, albeit incompletely. Use of 3D technology may facilitate adaptation of TAPP hernia repair by young surgeons.