L. Bonnard , L. Delaby , M. O’Donovan , M. Murphy , E. Ruelle
{"title":"Refining the soil and water component to improve the MoSt grass growth model","authors":"L. Bonnard , L. Delaby , M. O’Donovan , M. Murphy , E. Ruelle","doi":"10.1016/j.eja.2025.127520","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<div><div>Knowledge of previous and future grass growth is an important factor for grassland management decision making. It allows the farmer to predict the availability of grass for the herd on a short-term basis and adapt grassland management practise accordingly. The Moorepark St Gilles Grass Growth Model (MoSt GG) is used to predict grass growth weekly on 84 grassland farms across Ireland. The repeated use of the model on these farms has identified areas for improvement that have been addressed in this paper. Among these improvements, the soil sub-model component has been further developed to better represent different soil types and to account for different soil depths, improving the simulations of water and soil nitrogen fluxes (V2<sub>V1</sub><sub>+soil</sub>). A soil sub-layer of 10 cm was added to better simulate growth recovery after a drought period (V3<sub>V2+water</sub>). The radiation component was improved by including the day length in the grass growth estimation (V4<sub>V3+rad</sub>) instead of only accounting for daily cumulative solar radiation. These improvements were evaluated against several experiments conducted in Ireland and France. The developments improved model accuracy for every experiment evaluated. The RMSE in the original version of the model ranged from 322 to 1011 kg of DM/ha, whereas in the latest version of the MoSt GG model (V4<sub>V3+rad</sub>), the RMSE ranged from 312 to 671 kg of DM/ha. The further consideration of soil characteristics resulted in a higher variability in grass production and N leaching depending on soil type and weather conditions, leading to improved growth trend representation. The addition of the soil sub-layer (V3<sub>V2+water</sub>) improved the accuracy in drier years (French experiment) due to the more realistic grass growth recovery after a drought. The latest version of the model (V4<sub>V3+rad</sub>) simulates grass production more accurately than the previous versions and increases the reliability of grass growth prediction.</div></div>","PeriodicalId":51045,"journal":{"name":"European Journal of Agronomy","volume":"164 ","pages":"Article 127520"},"PeriodicalIF":5.5000,"publicationDate":"2025-02-06","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"European Journal of Agronomy","FirstCategoryId":"97","ListUrlMain":"https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1161030125000164","RegionNum":1,"RegionCategory":"农林科学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q1","JCRName":"AGRONOMY","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Knowledge of previous and future grass growth is an important factor for grassland management decision making. It allows the farmer to predict the availability of grass for the herd on a short-term basis and adapt grassland management practise accordingly. The Moorepark St Gilles Grass Growth Model (MoSt GG) is used to predict grass growth weekly on 84 grassland farms across Ireland. The repeated use of the model on these farms has identified areas for improvement that have been addressed in this paper. Among these improvements, the soil sub-model component has been further developed to better represent different soil types and to account for different soil depths, improving the simulations of water and soil nitrogen fluxes (V2V1+soil). A soil sub-layer of 10 cm was added to better simulate growth recovery after a drought period (V3V2+water). The radiation component was improved by including the day length in the grass growth estimation (V4V3+rad) instead of only accounting for daily cumulative solar radiation. These improvements were evaluated against several experiments conducted in Ireland and France. The developments improved model accuracy for every experiment evaluated. The RMSE in the original version of the model ranged from 322 to 1011 kg of DM/ha, whereas in the latest version of the MoSt GG model (V4V3+rad), the RMSE ranged from 312 to 671 kg of DM/ha. The further consideration of soil characteristics resulted in a higher variability in grass production and N leaching depending on soil type and weather conditions, leading to improved growth trend representation. The addition of the soil sub-layer (V3V2+water) improved the accuracy in drier years (French experiment) due to the more realistic grass growth recovery after a drought. The latest version of the model (V4V3+rad) simulates grass production more accurately than the previous versions and increases the reliability of grass growth prediction.
了解草地过去和未来的生长情况是草地管理决策的重要因素。它使农民能够在短期内预测牧草的可用性,并相应地调整草原管理实践。Moorepark St Gilles草生长模型(MoSt GG)用于预测爱尔兰84个草地农场每周的草生长情况。该模型在这些农场上的反复使用已经确定了本文中已经解决的有待改进的领域。在这些改进中,进一步开发了土壤子模型组件,以更好地代表不同的土壤类型和考虑不同的土壤深度,改进了水和土壤氮通量(V2V1+土壤)的模拟。为了更好地模拟干旱期(V3V2+水)后的生长恢复,增加了10 cm的土壤亚层。通过在草生长估算中加入日长(V4V3+rad)而不是只考虑日累积太阳辐射,提高了辐射分量。这些改进是根据在爱尔兰和法国进行的几项实验进行评估的。这些进展提高了每一个被评估实验的模型准确性。原始模型的RMSE为322 ~ 1011 kg DM/ha,而最新版本的MoSt GG模型(V4V3+rad)的RMSE为312 ~ 671 kg DM/ha。进一步考虑土壤特征,导致草产量和氮淋失随土壤类型和天气条件的变化更大,从而改善了生长趋势表征。土壤亚层(V3V2+水)的添加提高了干旱年份(法国试验)的准确性,因为干旱后草的生长恢复更加真实。最新版本的模型(V4V3+rad)比以前的版本更准确地模拟了草的生产,提高了草生长预测的可靠性。
期刊介绍:
The European Journal of Agronomy, the official journal of the European Society for Agronomy, publishes original research papers reporting experimental and theoretical contributions to field-based agronomy and crop science. The journal will consider research at the field level for agricultural, horticultural and tree crops, that uses comprehensive and explanatory approaches. The EJA covers the following topics:
crop physiology
crop production and management including irrigation, fertilization and soil management
agroclimatology and modelling
plant-soil relationships
crop quality and post-harvest physiology
farming and cropping systems
agroecosystems and the environment
crop-weed interactions and management
organic farming
horticultural crops
papers from the European Society for Agronomy bi-annual meetings
In determining the suitability of submitted articles for publication, particular scrutiny is placed on the degree of novelty and significance of the research and the extent to which it adds to existing knowledge in agronomy.