回复至:W. R. Berghuijs &;K. Hale Nature https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-024-08523-5(2025)。在他们的评论中,Berghuijs和hal1认为,比较高降雪量和低降雪量时期的流量时间是研究气候变暖对流量时间趋势影响的一种误导性类比2。他们的担忧是双重的:首先,他们断言直接分析流量时间趋势比比较不同时间段的降雪时间更合适;其次,他们认为,我们的研究结果表明,随着降雪量的变化,水流时间的变化主要是由降水的变化驱动的,而不是由气温上升驱动的。在本回应中,我们详细说明了这些担忧,并证明了它们为何无效。
期刊介绍:
Nature is a prestigious international journal that publishes peer-reviewed research in various scientific and technological fields. The selection of articles is based on criteria such as originality, importance, interdisciplinary relevance, timeliness, accessibility, elegance, and surprising conclusions. In addition to showcasing significant scientific advances, Nature delivers rapid, authoritative, insightful news, and interpretation of current and upcoming trends impacting science, scientists, and the broader public. The journal serves a dual purpose: firstly, to promptly share noteworthy scientific advances and foster discussions among scientists, and secondly, to ensure the swift dissemination of scientific results globally, emphasizing their significance for knowledge, culture, and daily life.