Under Pressure: Gifted Students' Vulnerabilities, Stressors, and Coping Mechanisms Within a High Achieving High School.

Abstract

This qualitative study explores the interactions among gifted students' vulnerabilities, stressors, supports, and coping mechanisms at a public, high-achieving residential high school. Qualitative interviews (n = 12) revealed that teachers caused stress by (a) failing to provide academic challenges and/or (b) failing to support students' diverse identities; conversely, teachers provided support when they were available, enthusiastic, and understanding. Further, peers added stress through class rank competition but fostered support through accepting diverse identities and building friendships. In general, students heavily relied on problem-focused coping to address academic stress (e.g., changing schools, advocacy), yet had minimal adaptative coping strategies to address social stress. Students also discussed hybrid coping approaches, like extracurriculars and counseling. These findings suggest that interventions, such as teacher training and peer support programs, should address specific vulnerabilities, including diverse identities, and provide direct instruction in developing coping strategies to address social stressors.