Widespread decoupling of spindles and slow waves in temporal lobe epilepsy

Abstract

Objective

Memory impairment is common in people with temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE). Recent studies in healthy subjects showed a positive correlation between sleep spindles coupled to slow waves (SWs) and memory performance. We aimed to determine differences in spindle–SW coupling in TLE patients compared to healthy controls using combined high-density electroencephalography and polysomnography.

Methods

The study population consisted of 20 patients (12 female, 36.5 ± 9.9 years old) with unilateral drug-resistant TLE (10 left temporal) and 20 age- and sex-matched controls (12 female, 31.2 ± 6.3 years old). Spindles (10–16 Hz, .5–3 s) and SWs (.5–4 Hz) were automatically detected during all N2 and N3 epochs using validated detectors. Coupling of spindles with SWs was defined as overlap between both detected events.

Results

Coupled spindle–SW rates (per minute) were globally reduced in patients with TLE compared to healthy controls (median = .18 [interquartile range (IQR) = .08–.36] vs. .35 [IQR = .24–.46], p = .014, d = −.46). This reduction was also found for coupled fast spindle (12–16 Hz)–SW (.06 [IQR = .02–.13] vs. .18 [IQR = .07–.25], p = .013, d = −.46) and slow spindle (10–12 Hz)–SW rates (.11 [IQR = .04–.23] vs. .19 [IQR = .13–.27], p = .034, d = −.40). Within TLE patients, there was no local difference between the coupling rates in the lobe with the epileptic focus compared to the contralateral side (.09 [IQR = .02–.13] vs. .07 [IQR = .02–.13], p = .18). The effect size of the reduction was stronger in early than late sleep for both N2 and N3 sleep (early N2 d = −.50 vs. late N2 d = −.39; early N3 d = −.53 vs. late N3 d = −.47).

Significance

Despite a focal epileptic generator, patients with unilateral TLE showed a widespread decoupling between sleep spindles and SWs that was most prominent in early sleep. As coupling was shown to be associated with neuropsychological performance in healthy people, this global decoupling may constitute one potential mechanism of poor memory performance in people with TLE.