{"title":"Optimizing the MoSt GG model a sensitivity-driven calibration for better grass growth forecasting","authors":"L. Bonnard , L. Delaby , M. Murphy , E. Ruelle","doi":"10.1016/j.compag.2025.110288","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<div><div>Grasslands offer an efficient and eco-friendly way to produce high-quality feed for ruminants, benefiting both livestock production and human nutrition. However, its high sensitivity to its environment makes its management challenging for farmers. Predicting week ahead grass growth results in better-informed decision making on farms. The Moorepark St Gilles Grass Growth Model (MoSt GG) has been used since 2018 to predict weekly grass growth on grassland farms across Ireland with 84 farms involved in 2023. The repeated use of the model on these farms has identified a need to improve its accuracy, which has been addressed in this study. First, a sensitivity analysis using the Morris method was conducted to identify the parameters that have the most influence on the model’s grass growth output, both on an annual and monthly time step. From that analysis, ten parameters were selected, all of which related either to temperatures, day length or nitrogen demand and availability for the grass. These ten parameters were calibrated using a semi-automatic iterative method of calibration on a dataset of 14 commercial farms containing four years of grass measurements. Nine iterations were necessary to calibrate the model resulting in a reduction of MAPE from 30.0% to 19.8% in its final calibrated version, and notably increasing the final R<sup>2</sup> from 0.58 to 0.71. Finally, the model was evaluated over a new dataset of ten commercial farms for four years. The evaluation confirmed the improvement of the model with a final MAPE of 19.1% and a R<sup>2</sup> of 0.67 compared to 30.1% and 0.57 respectively before the calibration. The calibration process of the MoSt GG model has significantly improved the model accuracy to predict on farm grass growth. This improvement is expected to be particularly valuable for farmers in their decision making process, providing them with more reliable on farm grass growth predictions.</div></div>","PeriodicalId":50627,"journal":{"name":"Computers and Electronics in Agriculture","volume":"235 ","pages":"Article 110288"},"PeriodicalIF":8.9000,"publicationDate":"2025-03-29","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Computers and Electronics in Agriculture","FirstCategoryId":"97","ListUrlMain":"https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0168169925003941","RegionNum":1,"RegionCategory":"农林科学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q1","JCRName":"AGRICULTURE, MULTIDISCIPLINARY","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Grasslands offer an efficient and eco-friendly way to produce high-quality feed for ruminants, benefiting both livestock production and human nutrition. However, its high sensitivity to its environment makes its management challenging for farmers. Predicting week ahead grass growth results in better-informed decision making on farms. The Moorepark St Gilles Grass Growth Model (MoSt GG) has been used since 2018 to predict weekly grass growth on grassland farms across Ireland with 84 farms involved in 2023. The repeated use of the model on these farms has identified a need to improve its accuracy, which has been addressed in this study. First, a sensitivity analysis using the Morris method was conducted to identify the parameters that have the most influence on the model’s grass growth output, both on an annual and monthly time step. From that analysis, ten parameters were selected, all of which related either to temperatures, day length or nitrogen demand and availability for the grass. These ten parameters were calibrated using a semi-automatic iterative method of calibration on a dataset of 14 commercial farms containing four years of grass measurements. Nine iterations were necessary to calibrate the model resulting in a reduction of MAPE from 30.0% to 19.8% in its final calibrated version, and notably increasing the final R2 from 0.58 to 0.71. Finally, the model was evaluated over a new dataset of ten commercial farms for four years. The evaluation confirmed the improvement of the model with a final MAPE of 19.1% and a R2 of 0.67 compared to 30.1% and 0.57 respectively before the calibration. The calibration process of the MoSt GG model has significantly improved the model accuracy to predict on farm grass growth. This improvement is expected to be particularly valuable for farmers in their decision making process, providing them with more reliable on farm grass growth predictions.
草原为反刍动物提供了一种高效、环保的饲料生产方式,既有利于畜牧生产,又有利于人类营养。然而,它对环境的高度敏感性给农民带来了管理上的挑战。提前一周预测草的生长情况可以使农场做出更明智的决策。Moorepark St Gilles草生长模型(MoSt GG)自2018年以来一直用于预测爱尔兰各地草地农场的每周草生长情况,2023年有84个农场参与其中。该模型在这些农场的反复使用表明需要提高其准确性,这在本研究中得到了解决。首先,使用Morris方法进行敏感性分析,以确定在年和月时间步长上对模型的草生长产量影响最大的参数。从分析中,选择了10个参数,所有这些参数都与温度、日长或草的氮需求和可用性有关。这10个参数使用半自动迭代校准方法在包含四年草测量的14个商业农场数据集上进行校准。需要9次迭代来校准模型,从而使最终校准版本的MAPE从30.0%降低到19.8%,并显着将最终R2从0.58提高到0.71。最后,在10个商业农场的新数据集上对该模型进行了四年的评估。最终MAPE为19.1%,R2为0.67,与校正前的30.1%和0.57相比,评价证实了模型的改进。MoSt GG模型的标定过程显著提高了模型对草地生长的预测精度。这一改进预计对农民在决策过程中特别有价值,为他们提供更可靠的农场草生长预测。
期刊介绍:
Computers and Electronics in Agriculture provides international coverage of advancements in computer hardware, software, electronic instrumentation, and control systems applied to agricultural challenges. Encompassing agronomy, horticulture, forestry, aquaculture, and animal farming, the journal publishes original papers, reviews, and applications notes. It explores the use of computers and electronics in plant or animal agricultural production, covering topics like agricultural soils, water, pests, controlled environments, and waste. The scope extends to on-farm post-harvest operations and relevant technologies, including artificial intelligence, sensors, machine vision, robotics, networking, and simulation modeling. Its companion journal, Smart Agricultural Technology, continues the focus on smart applications in production agriculture.